Skip to comments.
The Case for Physics First
The Washington Post ^
| February 8, 2003
| ROB SNYDER
Posted on 02/08/2003 5:34:19 AM PST by Archangelsk
The Case for Physics First
Saturday, February 8, 2003; Page A20
A Feb. 4 letter suggested that physics should not be taught before chemistry and biology because it is more abstract. But a first course in physics is the least abstract of any first-year high school science course.
Rather than having to imagine processes at an atomic or molecular level, or to imagine what occurs in biological systems, students in first-year physics can collect and analyze physical data as they experiment with falling objects, colliding carts, light bulbs, mirrors, etc.
(Excerpt) Read more at washingtonpost.com ...
TOPICS: Culture/Society
KEYWORDS: crevolist; physics
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-58 next last
To: Physicist
No child is left behind, because no child is permitted to run. A sad, but none-the-less apt characterization of the problem.
To: longshadow
Bump.
It's the math. I think the administrators would prefer to operate a school system with only slow children.
Smart kids intimidate them.
To: billorites
Simple Newtonian mechanics is easy for grade school kid to grok.An that makes those people I see going down the road at 70mph, 10 feet from the back bumper of the car in front of them, and absolutely no grasp of the concept of inertia all the more puzzling.
23
posted on
02/08/2003 9:24:48 AM PST
by
tacticalogic
(Controlled application of force is the sincerest form of communication.)
To: longshadow
This, in turn, requires students to understand and be fluent in things like "fractions" BEFORE they get their drivers license, which is a circuitous way of saying that that "feel-good" there-are-no-wrong-answers Math instruction needs to be banished forever from the classroom.My God, what kind of education system do you have in the States?!
To: longshadow
Given the problems inherent in the public education system, and the entrenched interests of incompetent teachers, bloated arrogant administrators, and their unions ... I can't dispute anything you've said. But I'm a disputatious person, and a good thread needs controversy -- hence my frustration. So let me say: You, sir, are descended from pond scum!
To: Youngblood
My God, what kind of education system do you have in the States?! The PUBLIC education system here, with a few exceptions, run by incompetent boobs, staffed with teachers who (with a few exceptions) are too stupid to get anything other than an education degree, and populated by students whose "Self-esteem" is deemed (by administrators and teachers) to be more important than their academic performance.
For a generation (or more), our schools have been riddled with leftist idiots who are preoccupied with "diversity," "self-esteem," "gender-based issues," and all sorts of academic egalitarian bullsh*t.
Heaven help you if you try to tell a student that he got a fraction problem "wrong" -- my goodness, that might harm his self-esteem, or, if it is a girl, it might cause her to feel she's being sexually discriminated against. Oh, dear, we could have that in our public schools, because we CARE SO MUCH..... (gag, cough).
To: tacticalogic
F=MA should be a pre-req for driving.
To: headsonpikes
Smart kids intimidate them. And with good reason; they have higher IQ's.
To: PatrickHenry
You, sir, are descended from pond scum! Where have I heard that before..... hmmmmm?
To: PatrickHenry
So let me say: You, sir, are descended from pond scum!As we all are. :-)
30
posted on
02/08/2003 9:50:24 AM PST
by
Archangelsk
(Ducking for cover now.)
To: longshadow; Archangelsk; Physicist
The high school I went to had (and maybe still does) a pretty good system. The standard 9th grade science class was Physical Sciences, which was essentially an intro course. The next three years focused on Biology, Chemistry, and Physics, in that order.
However, the more advanced incoming freshmen were given the option to skip the intro course, and jump into biology a year early. This allowed them to choose one of the three Advanced Placement science courses in chemistry, biology or physics for their senior year science class. At the end of the senior year, they could take the AP test for that subject. Colleges award credit hours (treated as tranferrable credits) for some of the core classes depending on how the students score on AP tests.
Of course, the high school administrators used all kinds of scare tactics (my parents even had to sign some kind of waiver) in order to discourage the parents from accelerating their kids.
31
posted on
02/08/2003 10:08:19 AM PST
by
Condorman
(Geography is just physics slowed down, with a few trees stuck in it)
To: PatrickHenry; longshadow
You, sir, are descended from pond scum!Sir, I've corresponded with longshadow for some time now. He's a good man. You, on the other hand, are made of monkey parts.
32
posted on
02/08/2003 10:18:13 AM PST
by
Condorman
("He feels he's a monkey trapped in the body of an ape." -Professor Monkey-for-a-Head)
To: Condorman
Of course, the high school administrators used all kinds of scare tactics (my parents even had to sign some kind of waiver) in order to discourage the parents from accelerating their kids. Indeed; the High School advisor told my parents it would be IMPOSSIBLE for me to take Physics as a freshman -- it took the intervention of the Physics teacher personally to arrange it. The advisor was convinced I was going to flunk.
By mid-year, I had an "A" in the course.
To: Wonder Warthog
The problem with having the math courses "run concurrently with the physics courses" is that they never really do. You invaribly hit a need in physics for a math concept you haven't yet had.But there's no reason you can't learn that concept in the physics course. There's nothing in my multivariable, linear and complex algebra, diff eq, and advanced math classes that I hadn't already picked up in my physics classes and utilized in the way I needed. I.e., I found the math to be more complimentary than essential. Perhaps the courses should just be combined.
When I tutor high school and freshman kiddies, I often find their trig and alg skills to be, frankly, dismal... Many simple physics problems can address this and strengthen their understanding of it, however, like vector motion or 2-d force problems for trig work...
It's true what you said about chemistry-- majored in chem as well, and all the others thought they'd died and gone to hell when the prof decided to waltz through quantum-mechanics-ultralite in physical chem class. Separation of Schodinger's equation in spherical coordinates was old hat to me by that time but the other kiddies would've much preferred going back to breathing benzene fumes... And they didn't even have to do the separation. [snortle]
And therein lies the problem-- kids just don't LIKE physics.
34
posted on
02/08/2003 10:31:28 AM PST
by
maxwell
(Well I'm sure I'd feel much worse if I weren't under such heavy sedation...)
To: Physicist; longshadow
Because in public education, they are forbidden from going faster than some bureaucrat (read: democrat) imagines the slowest child can go. No child is left behind, because no child is permitted to run. Tsk, tsk, who do you think you are to question the Handicapper General?
35
posted on
02/08/2003 10:49:09 AM PST
by
BMCDA
To: BMCDA
who do you think you are to question the Handicapper General? Clever.
36
posted on
02/08/2003 10:58:55 AM PST
by
Condorman
(We are what we pretend to be. -KV)
To: Archangelsk
F=ma is an algebra equation Huh?
It is not.
37
posted on
02/08/2003 11:28:24 AM PST
by
eniapmot
To: eniapmot
Well ok d(p)/d(t) = m d(d(x)/d(t))/d(t)
38
posted on
02/08/2003 11:34:44 AM PST
by
maxwell
(Well I'm sure I'd feel much worse if I weren't under such heavy sedation...)
To: Physicist; PatrickHenry
Thanks for the ping, PatrickHenry
Physicist,
I certainly agree that the high school science sequence is driven by math. (the need for Algebra II before Physics).
But the concepts ...can be introduced before the higher math. (See AAPT's Conceptual Force Quiz, which many physics graduate students might fail).
The result is, sadly that the middle school Physical Science (usually 8th grade) is the First Time students see Newton's Laws. And for most, it is the Last Time they study physics. (Few take high school physics.)
Paul Hewitt's "Conceptual Physics" is a good approach.
To: eniapmot; maxwell
Maxwell beat me to it.
40
posted on
02/08/2003 11:49:18 AM PST
by
Archangelsk
(Ducking for cover now.)
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-58 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson