Posted on 06/18/2002 2:19:55 PM PDT by Boxsford
Motive for Florida slaying a mystery
Jim Brown was killed May 25 in Pensacola, Fla., hours before he was to be married. Investigators are trying to determine whether Brown and the suspect in his death, William Harbour of Portsmouth, knew each other. Photo courtesy of the Brown family
By AMY JETER, The Virginian-Pilot © June 17, 2002
PORTSMOUTH -- On May 23, William Harbour kissed his wife goodbye and started a long drive from South Hampton Roads in a rented car. The Portsmouth attorney had blocked out more than a week of leave from his job with the U.S. Joint Forces Command to travel to Biloxi, Miss., for a job interview.
He did not make it back.
Two days after Harbour left, police arrested him near Perdido Key, a barrier island in the Florida panhandle near the Alabama state line. He is accused of fatally stabbing 51-year-old James Dudley Brown that morning, just hours before Brown was to be married.
A witness saw Harbour, 52, attack Brown with a long-bladed knife, change clothes, wipe blood from his body and pedal away from the crime scene on a bicycle, a Florida sheriff's report says.
Officers found Harbour riding his bike on a nearby road with bloody clothes in his backpack and what appeared to be a knife sheath attached to the bicycle.
Held without bond since his arrest, Harbour could face the death penalty or life imprisonment without parole if a grand jury decides later this month to upgrade his charges to first-degree murder.
Investigators and family members of both men have been searching for any previous connection between Brown and Harbour. None has found a clear answer.
But Harbour's attorney, James R. Stokes, said Friday the men were strangers, never meeting until minutes before Brown's slaying.
Harbour, he said, was defending his own life after a series of unfortunate coincidences led to a vicious fight.
Jim Brown grew up in Pensacola, tan and wiry, with the sun-bleached hair of a former surfer.
The 51-year-old loved to fish and boat, and was most at home sitting on the beach in a Panama hat, friends and family said. He had no need for wealth, but could afford luxuries.
``He drove an old pickup truck and wore raggedy shorts and T-shirts,'' said Mike Jones, a friend for about 20 years. ``He wouldn't buy anything for himself, but he bought his father a brand-new Mercedes.''
Brown worked with two brothers in the family business, Brown Helicopter. He often worked late managing inventory for the 18-year-old company, which buys and sells aircraft parts. The company has had numerous contracts with the U.S. Department of Defense.
Brown dated occasionally, but there was no one special until he rekindled an acquaintance with Angela Fell at a 30-year high school reunion. They planned to marry on May 25.
But Brown was apprehensive because of an incident two months earlier, said his sister, Kristine Peach, 53, of Mount Dora, Fla.
On March 18, a state fire marshal bomb squad dismantled a sophisticated bomb strapped under Jim Brown's truck at Brown Helicopter, according to news reports.
The federal Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms has been investigating but no charges had been filed early last week.
Brown believed his truck was at home when the bomb was fixed to it, Peach said, and told federal agents of his concerns that something may happen during his upcoming wedding.
According to Stokes, Brown's fears, coupled with finding a knife-wielding stranger on his property, may have led to his death.
Harbour, an attorney and outdoorsman, has been married to the same woman for more than three decades.
He attended college and law school in Arkansas, where a friend introduced him to his future wife, Linda. Their roomy Broad Street home in Portsmouth's Port Norfolk section was on the neighborhood's Holiday Home Tour in 1997, the year they moved in.
Harbour has been a civilian employee of the Defense Department for about two decades. During that time, he has worked at an Army chemical munitions repository in Pine Bluff, Ark., on a volunteer assignment to rebuild the Haitian government in 1994, and most recently at an Army base in Vicenza, Italy.
``He's very patriotic,'' said Linda Harbour, 50, a medical technician. ``He felt if he could help, he wanted to help.''
Once a marathoner and avid bike rider, Harbour was trying to get back in shape when he left for Mississippi, his wife said. He drove a rental car because he avoided flying whenever possible.
By May 25, Harbour already had interviewed in Biloxi and at least nine days of vacation remained, officials said. He was in Pensacola looking at waterfront property for retirement when the slaying occurred, Stokes said.
While Harbour is not talking to investigators, and the jail does not allow inmates to talk to the media, Stokes gave this account of what happened:
Harbour's search for land to buy took him to Brown's neighborhood. He rode his bicycle and carried a bayonet that he usually takes to dig up items when he uses a metal detector. This time, he used it to cut saw palmetto, a plant that eases prostate problems.
As he walked, Harbour crossed through Brown's property. Brown came outside and ordered him to leave.
Harbour made an inflammatory remark to Brown as he left.
Brown grabbed Harbour's shoulder. And when Harbour turned, Brown saw the knife.
The two men scuffled, Harbour holding on to the blade's point and the handle and Brown grabbing the middle.
At one point, Harbour heard Brown say, ``I'm going to kill you.''
Harbour remembers little else, other than falling from his bicycle as he rode away, Stokes said. He was in shock when he changed clothes, pedaled away and told officers, without mentioning the fight, that he was bloody because of the spill from his bike.
Harbour had brought a gun and ammunition for protection on his road trip, Stokes said. He left both in the car's trunk on that day, which proved he did not intend to kill someone, Stokes said.
Florida prosecutor David Rimmer said Harbour's account was not consistent with the evidence. Brown's house is elevated, he said, and blood was found in the area under the house, indicating that Harbour was not merely cutting through the property.
There is also evidence that Brown was fleeing, Rimmer said. Some of Brown's multiple stab wounds were to his back -- including a blow that severed his spinal cord. Also, Rimmer said, a large amount of blood trailed from the house across the street to where Brown was found.
That blood probably was not Harbour's, Rimmer said, because he sustained only a minor cut.
Peach, Brown's sister, didn't know what to make of it.
How could a seemingly routine exchange escalate to murder? she asked Friday. Why had no one indicated earlier that the slaying could be in self-defense?
``It sounds like somebody trying to make up a defense,'' Peach said. ``He just doesn't want to go to jail.''
Harbour's story won't stop her from looking for another motive, she said.
Bruce Wood, of the Escambia County Sheriff's Office, said investigators are exploring three possible connections between Harbour and Brown. One is through the Defense Department, which employed Harbour and did business with Brown Helicopter, he said. He declined to elaborate on the other theories.
Officials have investigated Harbour's possible involvement in the bomb incident. Harbour's wife and a spokesman for his employer say he was in Norfolk the day the explosive was found.
Brown's death, the third among seven siblings, has left the family reeling.
``The worse thing has happened,'' Peach said. ``No matter what the motive was, it can't be any worse than what we've been through.''
News researcher Jakon Hays, staff writer David Gulliver, 13 News and the Pensacola News Journal contributed to this report.
Reach Amy Jeter at ajeter@pilotonline.com or 446-2793.
Now it didn't say he had the metal detector so why did he have the "digger" ?? And in my personal experience I haven't met a lawyer yet that doesn't own a cell phone. Why if it was self defense or an attack did the "lawyer " leave the scene ??
If the lawyer was at home and work when the IED was placed on the vehicle originally I'd suggest a local disgruntled employee or neighbor (the one across the road IMHO is suspect based on blood spatter discussed in the thread).
Last but not least I have a theory on violence and trauma based on what I have seen in shootings and combat. People who were raised in a very peaceful environment, never had a hand raised against them in their life, no contact sports like football or wrestling /boxing will fall to pieces physically and mentally at the first hint of pain inflicted upon em. If this Lawyer was such a human being then that will answer a lot of the weird actions like riding away, changing his clothes and bewilderment ect ect ....
Tinfoil hat theory says the goobermint beancounter contract lawyer was using the goobermint contractor to divert funds to off shore account and someone was blackmailing the other and wahlahh ! Pigsticker solution # 5.............. There ya have may SWAG !!..............
Stay Safe ya'll !!
The bomb placed by the lawyer is moot as his Boss said he was at work a thousand miles north I believe (exact distance unknown) when suspect device was placed.
I rent cars to vacation in to save wear and tear and get a new one if I have a breakdown within an hour versus sitting at a dealer waiting to get something "bad" fixed. So that was plausable (with me anyway :o)
The guy has a history of bike riding daily so the bike is not a question either IMHO. Even had he not taken his own I suspect he'd have rented one to enjoy the Florida Sunshine ect ect.... and exercise.
In reality I just do not know. That's why the SWAG. My serious guess is a neighbor or co-worker did the bomb planting and the lawyer stumbled into the zone of this guys panic factor and killed in self defense and ,as a lawyer knows to shut his mouth till court hearing, we just won't hear what really happened till then IMHO....
Stay Safe !!
<<<"There is also evidence that Brown was fleeing, Rimmer said. Some of Brown's multiple stab wounds were to his back -- including a blow that severed his spinal cord. Also, Rimmer said, a large amount of blood trailed from the house across the street to where Brown was found. >>>
____________________________________________________________ AAAAAAHHHHHHHHH how we are intrigued by a mystery and this is an excellent one ...
On the face of it Harbour's story has lots of holes in it. It is possible for him to be where he was,(it stretches credulity doesn't it?) only it seems he went directly, to this rather out of the way location. He parked his car elsewhere and rode his bike to Brown's house. The stabbing with multiple stab wounds indicates much passion or deadly intent. Did he have 'Saw Palmetto' leaves with him when arrested? His taking it to cut Saw Palmetto as a treatment for the prostrate seems too thin an excuse.
<<< Harbour's search for land to buy took him to Brown's neighborhood. He rode his bicycle and carried a bayonet that he usually takes to dig up items when he uses a metal detector. This time, he used it to cut saw palmetto, a plant that eases prostate problems." >>>
There's much more to this story. Will it come to light? What person/attorney is prepared to kill another person without cause in such a manical way? Were these guys in Vietnam? On the front lines? Where the fighting was occurring?
This has been nagging at me. I am assuming it means he wanted out, due to his upcoming wedding, and feared they might not let him out.
Harbour may have feared Brown would go to the authorities, and went to confront him. Maybe he feared that if he waited until after the wedding, and the honeymoon trip from which Brown might not return, it would be too late.
Somebody stop me, I'm on a roll here.
I still like my "grand unified theory". A dealer in surplus military parts is in a perfect position to trans-ship high-tech weapons systems to third countries, with or without official approval. It takes an approved military surplus dealer, and someone on the inside to certify the equipment as "surplus". Oh, hey, maybe someone like a civilian lawyer for the Joint Forces Command.
Stay Safe Ann !!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.