Posted on 07/10/2023 7:43:25 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
An appeals court panel has struck down a block on a Tennessee act that bans prescribing body-disfiguring puberty blockers, opposite-sex hormones or sex-change surgeries from being performed on children and youth expressing confusion about their sex, allowing the state to enforce the law.
A three-judge panel of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled on Saturday that a Tennessee law passed back in March could take effect, removing a preliminary injunction placed on the act from a lower court.
Sixth Circuit Chief Judge Jeffrey Sutton, an appointee of former President George W. Bush, authored the opinion of the panel, concluding that “Tennessee is likely to succeed on its appeal of the preliminary injunction.”
Sutton noted that both sides of the litigation “have the same fear, just in opposite directions—one saying the procedures create health risks that cannot be undone, the other saying the absence of such procedures creates risks that cannot be undone.”
“If the injunction remains in place during the appeal, Tennessee will suffer irreparable harm from its inability to enforce the will of its legislature, to further the public-health considerations undergirding the law, and to avoid irreversible health risks to its children,” wrote Sutton.
“As for harm to others, the Act’s continuing care exception permits the challengers to continue their existing treatments until March 31, 2024. That feature of the law lessens the harm to those minors who wish to continue receiving treatment.”
Regarding debate over the merits of the law, Sutton added that “not every choice is for judges to make,” for “elected representatives made these precise cost-benefit decisions and did not trigger any reasons for skeptical review in doing so.”
“As for the public interest, Tennessee’s interests in applying the law to its residents and in being permitted to protect its children from health risks weigh heavily in favor of the State at this juncture,” Sutton continued.
Senior Judge Helene N. White authored an opinion that concurred in part and dissented in part from the panel opinion, writing that she believes the law was “likely unconstitutional based on Plaintiffs’ theory of sex discrimination.”
“Tennessee’s law likely discriminates against Plaintiffs on the basis of sex in violation of the Equal Protection Clause, thus triggering intermediate scrutiny,” wrote White.
“However, I agree that the district court abused its discretion in granting a statewide preliminary injunction … I would uphold the stay as it applies to Plaintiffs and also Vanderbilt University Medical Center.”
Tennessee Attorney General Jonathan Skrmetti released a statement in response to the panel decision, noting that while the decision was not the end of the litigation, it was a “big win.”
“The case is far from over, but this is a big win. The court of appeals lifted the injunction, meaning the law can be fully enforced, and recognized that Tennessee is likely to win the constitutional argument and the case,” stated Skrmetti.
Known as Senate Bill 1, or the Prohibition on Medical Procedures Performed on Minors Related to Sexual Identity, the act prohibits healthcare providers from performing genital mutilation surgeries or providing puberty blockers to minors suffering from confusion about their sex.
“The legislature declares that the integrity and public respect of the medical profession are significantly harmed by healthcare providers performing or administering such medical procedures on minors. This state has a legitimate, substantial, and compelling interest in protecting minors from physical and emotional harm,” stated the findings of the legislation.
“This state has a legitimate, substantial, and compelling interest in protecting the integrity of the medical profession, including by prohibiting medical procedures that are harmful, unethical, immoral, experimental, or unsupported by high-quality or long-term studies, or that might encourage minors to become disdainful of their sex.”
In April, the Tennessee chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, Lambda Legal and others sued the state over the new law on behalf of trans-identified minors and their families.
Additionally, in April, the U.S. Department of Justice filed a complaint in intervention on behalf of the families suing the state, claiming that the law “prohibits certain forms of medically necessary care for transgender minors.”
Wow!! You can’t kill your baby or cut his weener off in Tennessee. That should help quell the liberal invasion.
Sure hope so...
I’m sure more lawsuits will be filed as time goes on.
The liberals are taking the position, that there is a constitutional right, for children to have transgender surgery and cross sex hormone shots and puberty blockers.
Here we go. They are suing for the legal right to do this.
The liberals are also talking about how there are all these “anti LGBT” laws being passed in states around the country. ‘
You might have thought activist types would have been euphoric and their lives complete, when the Supreme Court imposed homosexual marriage on the country. But instead, they moved the goal posts and are now pushing all this transsexual business.
And again taking the position, that anyone opposed is some sort of bigot and hater.
These suits should make kids think more. The problem is those pushing this fantasy.
It’s amazing to me that the Left is so aggressive about castrating and sterilizing children and turning them into sex toys. Its beginning to looking like Sodom and Gomorrah. Did these people not learn from history that this is not going to go well?
No they didn’t learn from history, because the people pushing this are not familiar with The Bible.
As the parent of a transgender child (now an adult), I can state unequivocally that transitioning children is always medically unnecessary and runs contrary to actual known science.
This is ghoulish.
My child’s congenital endocrine disorder is rare. Most of the genetic disorders that can give rise to gender dysphoria are rare. Further, gender dysphoria may be a temporary condition that subsides once puberty ends.
Unfortunately, that was not the case for my child. Their condition is an incurable and painful life sentence.
It is statistically impossible for all these kids to be trans. This is social contagion.
I am sick and tired of these monsters using my child’s hellish medical condition to push their agenda-driven garbage.
I hope it does!
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.