Posted on 10/11/2022 8:21:01 AM PDT by Navy Patriot
Being too old may not be the only reason many of us will not live to see it. Maybe war, or maybe the end times are nearer. Keep well and keep at Peace.
P.S., I fully understand why you prefer the Strength of Amendment and Ratification, the People Speak through their Representatives, bringing the People closer to their Constitution.
According to the SCOTUS.
Thank you, Godspeed.
I think this is the right decision. Since the Constitution doesn’t address this issue specifically. The SCOTUS should not make a ruling on this, and leave this issue to the legislature of the various states.
The SCOTUS does not exist so the the justices can insert their own opinions into the law. They are there to interpret the law and the Constitution.
If people want a fetal personhood law, get their legislature to pass one. Don’t ask the SCOTUS to create it.
“bringing the People closer to their Constitution”
In my view, bringing the Constitution closer to the people.
In their brilliance the founders knew what they gave us was not perfect, only the best they could do, and instead of projecting us to rely on more revolutions they installed the ability for us - the people - to change what they gave us, peacefully. That has worked, many times. Unlike France we are not on our nth Republic since our founding, and unlike the U.K. we have a formal Constitution that mere federal legislation alone cannot change. I think ours is the better of the three systems. Not perfect, just the best.
Sometimes I get things backward.
A well thought out reply that has considerable support on this thread.
This is the part that is law:
That these United Colonies are, and of Right ought to be Free and Independent States; that they are Absolved from all Allegiance to the British Crown, and that all political connection between them and the State of Great Britain, is and ought to be totally dissolved; and that as Free and Independent States, they have full Power to levy War, conclude Peace, contract Alliances, establish Commerce, and to do all other Acts and Things which Independent States may of right do.
We said that was how it was, the British legal system disagreed and so we had a war.
We won by the way.
And then the British signed a piece of paper that said we were no longer their property and that, by being a treaty, became law.
And then we had another war because they had their fingers crossed on some parts. We won that war too.
It ended with another treaty.
And this time they stuck to the terms and so we are now friends.
Why is that Congress's job?
In all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls, and those in which a State shall be Party, the supreme Court shall have original Jurisdiction. In all the other Cases before mentioned, the supreme Court shall have appellate Jurisdiction, both as to Law and Fact, with such Exceptions, and under such Regulations as the Congress shall make.
So, Congress does have an express role of determining the jurisdiction of the courts.
So the British legally declared our independence for us?
They recognized it with the treaty.
Until they did our independence was considered quazi-legal at best by other countries.
Some recognized it as legal to dunk on the Brits. Still it was with reservations in case we lost.
Some did not to keep British favor or to prevent their own colonies from getting ideas.
But once the treaty was signed by both parties it became legal.
If the British had never recognized it many other countries would not have either, at least not officially.
I can’t take credit. Alan Keyes pointed this out when he was running for president.
So our independence is only legal because other countries recognized it?
You can have a passport declaring yourself a citizen of the free state of me and it is not legal unless it is recognized as legal by other states.
“I would reply that Justice Delayed is Justice Denied.”
I kinda look at it as no news is good news. The more the courts stay out of government operations, the more control the people have with the control they have been stripped of over the last hundred years. I don’t need overgrown lawyers interpreting what the agenda driven elected officials wish to get by with and make it more confusing than it was. Especially when the judges wish to comingle foreign laws into their evaluation and make it the one size fits all it could be in other countries, but not here. This happening while they continue to hide behind each other until they can spin away what they are doing in their own screwed up little world that will take years to narrow down and correct.
wy69
That was my immediate first thought also. 100%.
Good point, that is true for courts like SCOTUS (the case here) with lifetime appointments. There may be more accountability in State and Muni Courts where Judges must stand for Election (Remembering that courts are actually part of the Government, and the best Government is the least Government.
I don’t need overgrown lawyers interpreting what the agenda driven elected officials wish to get by with and make it more confusing than it was.
No honest American does, Shyster Lawyers that weaponize Law and Courts against John Ordinary Public for control and thievery, are the norm in America now.
Additionally, proposed Law is written to do the opposite of what John Ordinary Public wants and named to fool John Ordinary Public into supporting those Laws.
Especially when the judges wish to comingle foreign laws into their evaluation...
This is one of the Globo (as in GloboHomoNazi) goals, and has been since the League of Nations went the way the UN should.
...they (Biased Judges & Shyster Lawyers) continue to hide behind each other until they can spin away what they are doing in their own screwed up little world that will take years to narrow down and correct.
If ever.
I don't have an answer for you, (and remember, we are talking about people that think it's noble to kill a defenseless baby and grant special privilege to a Homosexual Pedophile Human Trafficker).
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.