Posted on 04/28/2020 4:11:32 AM PDT by Kaslin
All my life, I have dismissed paranoids on the right ("America is headed to communism") and the left ("It can happen here" -- referring to fascism). It's not that I've ever believed liberty was guaranteed. Being familiar with history and a pessimist regarding the human condition, I never believed that.
But the ease with which police state tactics have been employed and the equal ease with which most Americans have accepted them have been breathtaking.
People will argue that a temporary police state has been justified because of the allegedly unique threat to life posed by the new coronavirus. I do not believe the data will bear that out. Regardless, let us at least agree that we are closer to a police state than ever in American history.
"Police state" does not mean totalitarian state. America is not a totalitarian state; we still have many freedoms. In a totalitarian state, this article could not be legally published, and if it were illegally published, I would be imprisoned and/or executed. But we are presently living with all four of the key hallmarks of a police state:
No. 1: Draconian laws depriving citizens of elementary civil rights.
The federal, state, county and city governments are now restricting almost every freedom except those of travel and speech. Americans have been banned from going to work (and thereby earning a living), meeting in groups (both indoors and outdoors), meeting in their cars in church parking lots to pray and entering state-owned properties such as beaches and parks -- among many other prohibitions.
No. 2: A mass media supportive of the state's messaging and deprivation of rights.
The New York Times, CNN and every other mainstream mass medium -- except Fox News, The Wall Street Journal (editorial and opinion pages only) and talk radio -- have served the cause of state control over individual Americans' lives just as Pravda served the Soviet government. In fact, there is almost no more dissent in The New York Times than there was in Pravda. And the Big Tech platforms are removing posts about the virus and potential treatments they deem "misinformation."
No. 3: Use of police.
Police departments throughout America have agreed to enforce these laws and edicts with what can only be described as frightening alacrity. After hearing me describe police giving summonses to, or even arresting, people for playing baseball with their children on a beach, jogging alone without a mask, or worshipping on Easter while sitting isolated in their cars in a church parking lot, a police officer called my show. He explained that the police have no choice. They must respond to every dispatch they receive.
"And why are they dispatched to a person jogging on a beach or sitting alone in a park?" I asked.
Because the department was informed about these lawbreakers.
"And who told the police about these lawbreakers?" I asked.
His answer brings us to the fourth characteristic of a police state:
No. 4: Snitches.
How do the police dispatchers learn of lawbreakers such as families playing softball in a public park, lone joggers without face masks, etc.? From their fellow citizens snitching on them. The mayor of New York City, Bill de Blasio, set up a "snitch line," whereby New Yorkers were told to send authorities photos of fellow New Yorkers violating any of the quarantine laws. Los Angeles Mayor Eric Garcetti similarly encouraged snitching, unabashedly using the term.
It is said that about 1 in every 100 East German citizens were informers for the Stasi, the East German secret police, as superbly portrayed in the film "The Lives of Others." It would be interesting, and, I think, important, to know what percentage of New Yorkers informed on their fellow citizens. Now, again, you may think such a comparison is not morally valid, that de Blasio's call to New Yorkers to serve a Stasi-like role was morally justified given the coronavirus pandemic. But you cannot deny it is Stasi-like or that, other than identifying spies during World War II, this is unprecedented in American history at anywhere near this level.
This past Friday night, I gathered with six others for a Shabbat dinner with friends in Santa Monica, California. On my Friday radio show, I announced I would be doing that, and if I was arrested, it would be worth it. In my most pessimistic dreams, I never imagined that in America, having dinner at a friend's house would be an act of civil disobedience, perhaps even a criminal act. But that is precisely what happens in a police state.
The reason I believe this is a dress rehearsal is that too many Americans appear untroubled by it; the dominant force in America, the left, supports it, and one of the two major political parties has been taken over by the left. Democrats and their supporters have, in effect, announced they will use state power to enforce any law they can to combat the even greater "existential" crisis of global warming.
On the CNN website this weekend, in one of the most frightening and fanatical articles in an era of fanaticism, Bill Weir, CNN chief climate correspondent, wrote an open letter to his newborn son. In it, he wrote of his idealized future for America: "completely new forms of power, food, construction, transportation, economics and politics."
You cannot get there without a police state.
If you love liberty, you must see that it is jeopardized more than at any time since America's founding. And that means, among other things, that at this time, a vote for any Democrat is a vote to end liberty.
Just because YOU got scared doesn't mean I have to lose my livelihood.
most people are just wimpy go-alongs....look at the fearpers...
Because we are tolerating it.
I’m quite impressed with the sense of resistance that is being displayed by the churches in Greenville MS, and by our own Alberta’s Child...
At the same time, I’m still appalled by these cries to “let my people go” from so many here on FR.
There’s no difference to begging for protection from the virus and begging for permission to live your life as you see fit.
It’s still begging.
You’re the one who’s scared. If you lose your livelihood it’s because you didn’t defend it.
Ping, with my apologies for the mention without the courtesy.
Think of the liberties we lost after 911. The Patriot Act. Then NDAA which basically gives the President unlimited powers during a national emergency. The state and local governments are always happy to one up the Feds on tyranny. These acts of tyranny at the local level are more concerning and we should all be pushing back on these people in the aftermath. You are totally right about this.
Truth bomb!
As I’ve said ... I am fortunate in that my work is done in an office and can easily be done “out of sight” most of the time. I’d probably be out of business if I had a restaurant or another business establishment that is a “public accommodation.”
And I’ll tell you what ... If I was driven out of business here in my state due to these outrageous government edicts, I’d be packing everything I owned and moving to South Dakota tomorrow.
You are right about the freepers. I had some just excoriating me for daring to mention that the statistics just didn’t add up to an epidemic worthy of shutting the country down. Now it looks like I was right and those freepers have shrunk back into the shadows. It was very eye opening.
“I always wondered how Hitler got the population so willing to comply, and the police to become so cruel.”
Hitler propagandized that Jews were the cause of their economic problems, made Jews every German’s enemy.
Now, “messages” here have made non-compliers (with state governors’ dictates) everyone’s enemy, and has caused us very hurtful economic and supply chain problems.
Yep, your opinion. Suggest you read our DOI and COTUS.
Not to mention all the people employed at said businesses. Of course, the fact that we're destroying the lives of millions is a small price to pay given there is apparently a virus around./s
I’m familiar with them, as they are at the root of my political beliefs and the opinion that I have stated.
What do you suggest I refresh myself on, specifically?
Opportunity,,
I’m looking for It!
Donald trump started the ball rolling and he criticizes those that want to allow people to go back to work now.
He is letting democrats lead him around by the nose.
Hi.
We have been planning for a police state for five decades.
All we need now is a 81mm mortar and ordinance.
5.56mm
Fixed it...
Bump
60 %? Really? I’m here every day and I haven’t seen that.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.