Posted on 03/21/2014 10:25:55 AM PDT by Fractal Trader
Today the Alabama Supreme Court issued its 7-2 decision in the case of McInnish v. Chapman, and the decision goes against plaintiffs Hugh Chapman and Virgil Goode, who were trying to force the Alabama Secretary of State to verify Obama’s eligibility to be on the 2102 Alabama presidential ballot. Larry Klayman was the attorney for the Appellants.
The Court’s Majority issued no written opinion, only affirming the lower court decision dismissing the case.
Majority decision to affirm, no opinion (Stuart, Murdock, Shaw, Main, Wise) Concurring opinion (Bolin) Concurring opinion (Bryan) Dissenting Opinion (Moore) Dissenting Opinion (Parker) Chief Justice Roy Moore issued the major dissenting opinion, and Justice Bolin issued a concurring opinion specifically addressed to Moore’s dissent. Chief Justice Moore states that under Alabama Law, Secretary of State Chapman has an affirmative duty to verify candidate eligibility. Justice Bolin agrees that candidate eligibility is an important public interest, but that Alabama statutes do not place a duty on the Secretary of State to verify it. Further Justice Bolin points out that Secretary of State Chapman is a nonjudicial officer with no subpoena power or investigative authority. Justice Bolin concludes:
Under our current structure, however, the burden of investigating a presidential candidate’s qualifications is best left – unfortunately or not – to the candidate’s political party….
As I understand his position, Justice Bolin is saying that a state statute requiring verification of eligibility for candidates for president is a desirable thing, given his belief that the federal courts are prohibited from adjudicating eligibility because of the Political Question Doctrine.
Justice Bryan also issued a concurring opinion, briefly stating his belief that legislation could be passed to allow verification of candidate eligibility.
Chief Justice Moore’s dissenting opinion goes to the details of the Alabama statutes involved and at a brief reading has no particular high points. It is an analysis on the merits.
Chief Justice Parker also dissents from the majority opinion, supporting the analysis of Chief Justice Moore, but disagreeing on the Secretary of State’s affirmative duty to investigate candidate eligibility.
A text search of all of the opinions affirms my opinion that the Affidavit of Mike Zullo is irrelevant, being cited not onc
He’s a FogBlower.
I think Burning Oak is Foggy.
LOL... ;)
You don't get it, do you? If they already "have the goods," then it's their legal and ethical duty to file charges today. If they don't have the goods yet, and merely believe that "it's going to happen," then they have an equal duty to not talk about it until it happens because, if they don't yet have the goods, it may not happen.
I'll ask again: what prosecutor's office gives a press conference before they're ready to file charges?
The one that’s going after the king.
I'll ask again: what prosecutor's office gives a press conference before they're ready to file charges?
Many law enforcement agencies across the country have given pressers while in the middle of conducting criminal investigations. It happens all the time especially high profile cases in the news. As their criminal case builds, it will be Sheriff Arpaio who will make the determination when to turn the evidence over to the prosecutor's office.
Yes he could be Floggy or works with him.
Thank you for your assessment. Legalese stuff always aggravates me so much plus I have a hard time wading through it, don’t have the right kind of brain.
Thanks, I’ll listen tomorrow.
I like how you think.
Taitz is excited about finally scoring that the SSA has confirmed Obama’s is fraudulently using Bounel’s SSN.
From her website:
“Press release Social Security Administration admits that they have records for Bounel, they claim the records are with the Office of Earnings Operations
Press release
Law Offices of Orly Taitz
Investigator, Mr. Brewer , working with attorney Taitz, finally received a confirmation from the SSA that they indeed have records of Harry Bounel, whose SSN 042-68-4425 Obama is using. It is interesting that they released without problems records of other deceased individuals, such as Thomas Wood, whose SSN 042-68-4424 is just one before Bouel’s, but they stated that the Bounel’s social Security application is with the Office of Earnings Operations.
Why would his Social Security application be with the Office of the Earnings Operatons? Bounel was born in Russia in 1890, he was a poor man with only 3 grades of elementary education, he worked as a cash laborer in a fruit store in Bronx, NY. It looks like Social Security Senior FOIA officer, Attorney Dawn Wiggins, is bailing out of this RICO conspiracy and does not want to get a life sentence of death penalty for being a part of the RICO conspiracy to commit treason and cover up identity theft and use of a stolen Social Security number by a person occupying the office of the U.S. President. This is Watergate -2 unfolding. Previously she claimed that SSA does not have Bounel’s records.
What is more troubling, is that the President of Russia, Vladimir Putin, has all of this information too, as Bounel was a Russian citizen before immigrating to the U.S. Putin can blackmail Obama with these stolen IDs as much as he wants, he can get anything he wants, so can allies of Putin, countries like Iran, Syria and China.
Attorney Orly Taitz submitted all of the additional information to Judge Hollander, who already made 2 good decisions in this case, and who is expected to render her final ruling any day now
Law Offices Dr. Orly Taitz, ESQ”
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
However those clown CONs at Dr. CONpiracy are proffering or hoping that Taitz got punked.
It looks like Orly finally scored. See the above post at 71.
And this exchange between Taitz and Keith Davidson, aka Dr. CON:
“Kevin Davidson
March 21st, 2014 @ 1:08 pm
It looks like you have been punked again with yet another faked document.
dr_taitz@yahoo.com
March 21st, 2014 @ 3:08 pm
no, I was not, I have both pages and other responses from SSA to this person. Wishful thinking Kevin, if you believe that this is punked, wishful thinking, but no such luck for you.”
So the Harrison Bounel thing is real.
Interesting.
Yeah it’s real. This is great gravy on top of what Arpaio/Zullo have to spring about Obama’s criminality. It means Obama does not have a genuine issued social security number that he can call his own, and he is fraudulently using another. It looks to be the real deal, but will see for sure in short order.
The ramifications are going to be bad for you know who in the White House.
Thanks for the ping, and I enjoyed your comments today over at BR...
“Investigator, Mr. Brewer , working with attorney Taitz, finally received a confirmation from the SSA that they indeed have records of Harry Bounel, whose SSN 042-68-4425 Obama is using.”
The way I read this is that Brewer confirmed that they have records for Bounel but NOT that he had the same SSN as BArry’s. The part of the sentence after the word Bounel seems to have bee added as an assumption by Dr. Taitz...as yet unproved, it seems, IMO. We shall see...
Another exchange between an OBot and Taitz.
- - - - - - -
” Annie Daynow
March 21st, 2014 @ 5:50 pm
Your are mistaken. ALL SS-5 requests are handled by the Office of Earnings Operations. It doesn’t matter if the request has anything to do with earnings. See the form for making SS-5 requests. It is supposed to be sent to OEO.
http://www.ssa.gov/online/ssa-711.pdf
Mr. Brewer obviously sent his request to the wrong office.
dr_taitz@yahoo.com
March 21st, 2014 @ 6:24 pm
no, he did not. He requested under 120 year rule. also, the FOIA was sent in October of 2013, they were supposed to respond within 20 working days and they did not respond for 5 months. Now they are saying to go to another office. They suddenly responded after I sent Brewer’s letter to Judge Hollander. PS a letter from Wiggins preceded this letter and Wiggins released records of other people, so obviously he sent to the right office “
All the letter says is that they are referring Brewer’s request to a new office. It says nothing at all about Bounel existing or his SSN. What the heck is Orly smoking?
The letter says this:
This letter is in response to your February 3, 2014 inquiry to Acting Commissioner Colvin concerning your request for the late Mr. Harrison J. Bounel’s Social Security records. The records you requested are under the jurisdiction of our Office of Earnings Operations. We are referring your inquiry to that office. The officials there will look into the situation you described and reply directly to you. You should hear from them soon.
Also interesting is your comment above regarding a lot of new info in the last five months.
And also the part about his past life and lying. He has a fake life.
I wonder how much of it they are unraveling.
I’m on pins and needles.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.