Posted on 09/13/2011 12:51:57 PM PDT by Cincinatus' Wife
Ive been leaning towards Rick Perry for a few weeks with Michele Bachmann as my second choice if he implodes. My first preference didnt change last night but my second place choice did.
Last night Michele Bachmann lost my support.
She not only lost it for consideration as a presidential nominee, she lost it period. Full stop. In my view she beclowned herself beyond redemption and the sooner she disappears from the national stage the better.
For reasons that seem to have more to do with being behind Ron Paul in the polls and trying to scab some of the Paul supporters than any policy reason she made an unhinged attack on Perry on what should be a non-issue: his never-implemented executive order making mandatory a vaccine to protect women against a virus known to cause cervical cancer. What is worse she insisted that a fringe position is, in fact, a touchstone of conservatism.
From the transcript
BACHMANN: Im a mom. And Im a mom of three children. And to have innocent little 12-year-old girls be forced to have a government injection through an executive order is just flat out wrong. That should never be done. Its a violation of a liberty interest.
Thats little girls who have a negative reaction to this potentially dangerous drug dont get a mulligan. They dont get a do- over. The parents dont get a do-over. Thats why I fought so hard in Washington, D.C., against President Obama and Obamacare.
President Obama in a stunning, shocking level of power now just recently told all private insurance companies, you must offer the morning-after abortion pill, because I said so. And it must be free of charge. That same level coming through executive orders and through government dictates is wrong. And thats why again we have to have someone who is absolutely committed to the repeal of Obamacare and I am. I wont rest until its appealed.
She followed up with Greta van Susteren (skip to 1:58) in her post debate interview by saying
The problem is, it comes with some very significant consequences. Theres a woman who came up crying to me tonight after the debate. She said her daughter was given that vaccine. She told me her daughter suffered mental retardation as a result of that vaccine. There are very dangerous consequences. Its not good enough to take, quote, a mulligan where you want a do-over, not when you have little childrens lives at risk.
There are several threads of crazy running through this which leads one to believe that Bachmann, who if not anti-vaccine herself, was playing to the confusion the anti-vaccine fringe has managed to throw into what should be a fairly straightforward public policy debate.
As Ben Domenech points out in his indispensable The Transom:
But heres the real reason this is a silly debate: the policy never went into effect. Not one girl was vaccinated under the policy. Not one shot was given. Demanding apologies from Perry for a policy that never went into effect gets tiresome after a while particularly when Mitt Romney has never apologized for his namesake health care reforms, in effect in Massachusetts still today.
There is much to be criticized in the way Perry acted but no one received a government injection, whatever that may be. (For a more detailed take on what is wrong with the fringe anti-Gardasil argument visit Ace. It is worth the read.)
Lets take the easy parts first. The HPV vaccine is safe. Some 26 million doses have been distributed in the United States and to date there have been about 1500 reports of serious incidents
A serious incident is defined as:
Any VAERS (Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System) report that indicated hospitalization, permanent disability, life-threatening illness, congenital anomaly or death is classified as serious. As with all VAERS reports, serious events may or may not have been caused by the vaccine. [italics mine]
Despite what you may read there is not a single fatality associated with the vaccine. Again from the CDC:
In the 32 reports confirmed, there was no unusual pattern or clustering to the deaths that would suggest that they were caused by the vaccine and some reports indicated a cause of death unrelated to vaccination. [italics mine]
The claim that Gardasil caused mental retardation is specious and seems calculated to appeal to the vaccines-cause-autism fringe. The international patient advocacy group, the Global and Regional Asperger Syndrome Partership, an organization with a vested interest in finding what causes Asperger Syndrome and autism, says:
Congresswoman Bachmanns decision to spread fear of vaccines is dangerous and irresponsible. There is zero credible scientific evidence that vaccines cause mental retardation or autism. She should cease trying to foment fear in order to advance her political agenda.
Regularly on these threads we get people advocating abstinence as a way of combating HPV. Because sex, you know, merits cancer. The idea that we should allow some diseases free rein because we dont like how they are spread strikes me as silly. Evidence indicates personal abstinence doesnt work in regards to preventing the spread of HPV. It isnt sufficient that you be abstinent. Your spouse must also have been abstinent prior to marriage and any/all former sexual partners of your spouse must have been abstinent. In the United States, by age 50 at least 80% of women will be infected with HPV.
While Bachmann is right, there is no do-over for girls who may be injured by the vaccine, she seems a lot less concerned that there is also no do-over for women who die from cervical cancer that could have been prevented. In this case Bachmanns policy preference is the avoidance of hypothetical risk rather than preventing a real disease that kills people. This type of fuzzy or cynically opportunistic thinking is not what we need.
The liberty interest argument is just as silly. Unless youre going to argue that every mandatory vaccine like fluoridated water is an affront to some liberty interest, using this line of attack on a vaccination that was always subject to parental consent simply defines liberty down to an absence of any personal or parental responsibility.
This particular attack was an own-goal by Bachmann in every conceivable way. It plays into the anti-science meme with which the Left is trying to festoon conservatism. Her constant invocation of little and innocent children gives one flashbacks to Hillary Clinton and her tossing the for the children mantra about. It was a senseless attack on Perry that played well with a segment of the debate studio audience. But it is one that makes Bachmann look extreme to the majority of GOP voters while making Perry more acceptable to nearly everyone else. If her goal was to take the lead from Rick Perry, something she cant do even by the addition of all of Ron Pauls supporters, she chose a suboptimal tactic.
The real question for Bachmann is, if you had a vaccine that you knew prevented your kids from developing cancer would you support it being available. This is all Perry did. His executive order made a very expensive vaccine affordable while at the same time allowing anyone who wanted to opt out to do so. This isnt progressivism or liberalism. It isnt even compassionate conservatism. It is common sense. In fact, it is exactly what Sarah Palin did as governor of Alaska.
"When both the House and Senate repealed the (vaccination) law six weeks later, Perry did not as he now claims listen humbly or agree with their decision.Human shield demagoguery. In response to the legislatures rebuke, the infuriated governor attacked those who supported repeal as shameful spreaders of misinformation who were putting womens lives at risk. Borrowing a tried-and-true Alinskyite page from the progressive left, Perry surrounded himself with female cervical cancer victims and deflected criticism of his imperial tactics with emotional anecdotes.
He then lionized himself and the minority of politicians who voted against repeal of his Gardasil order. They will never have to think twice about whether they did the right thing. No lost lives will occupy the confines of their conscience, sacrificed on the altar of political expediency. Perry, of course, has now put his own ghastly Gardasil order on that same altar but with no apology to all those he demonized and exploited along the way."
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2777761/posts
That is one of the things that bothers me the most.
Maybe she meant to say she has three girls.
Ah. Okay.
I agree. It's a shame that Sarah Palin decided to echo the charge on Greta as well.
It sounds to me as though the state legislature may have made the right move for the wrong reasons.
>>It sounds to me as though the state legislature may have made the right move for the wrong reasons.<<
The issue is Perry and his horrible decisions.
BTW, I don't see this as anything worse than a temporary lapse in judgment by Governor Perry and I have regard for Michelle Bachmann but she should not go overboard on the issue by accusing Perry of corruption without more evidence than a $5,000 contribution or a $30,000 contribution in the context of a $30 million re-election campaign.
You couldn’t be more off-base with your attack. Go pound sand.
Last night Michele Bachmann lost my support.
I agree completely. Instead of a legitimate criticism about the mandate, she regurgitated anti-vaccination propaganda. The mental retardation comment was shameful, as was the retort about young girls and mothers "not having a choice."
What is PerryCare?
I’ve never lost respect for a candidate as quickly as I did last night for Bachmann. It was sickening.
Bachmann showed more guts than anyone on stage. And was dead on accurate. No real conservative can consider Perry anything other than a W. Bush mark II. We have no more time for RINOs that are covert.
Rove has shown over and over ...he truly HATES the T-Party, or anyone who truly wishes for a return to Constitutionalism.
I’m with the author. Bachmann cried crocodile tears last night and someone should count how many times she said, “innocent, little, twelve year old girls.” She had to have rehearsed it and Bachmann and Romney teamed up to attack Perry when in the past, Romney was the liberal in the bunch. Why is Bachmann helping Romney? This woman has misplaced priorities.
It was Bachmann who teamed up with Romney. Not one child ever had one of these shots. Why isn’t there outrage over mandates for other vaccines? It’s just generally accepted. Romney and Bachmann was an opportunity to make points of a non issue. Fortunately, it has backfired on Bachmann. I hope she’s done.
Just remember Bachmann sold out to RINO Romney.
The only way they THINK in their little corrupt pee brains to get Perry was to team up together. Michele made a huge mistake in teaming up with the enemy...and we saw her lose most of her support by her actions. IF she’d let herself be led of The Lord...she’d have never stepped acrossed that line. She did and is now the bigger of the losers. I hope her internals has shown her just how much she truly has tanked. Talk about shooting herself in both feet.
That’s the way I see it, too. She sided up with the enemy but who knows the real reason why but nevertheless, she sold out.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.