Posted on 12/18/2010 8:01:19 AM PST by IbJensen
Pornography has invaded the world’s imagination. It is everywhere: On the Internet, in films, in movies, in rap music videos. Five-year-old girls dress and are taught to behave like pornography stars in order to win beauty contests. Ten- to twelve-year-old girls both dress and behave like the pornographic images that surround them—and they provide sexual services to young boys.
Opera—high culture—has also been increasingly “sexed up.” I have seen productions of “Carmen” and “Lulu” in which the lead diva was half-naked and in which she, too, sang the role as if she was a contemporary pornography star and prostitute.
No, I do not like any of this.
Yes, I take it all very seriously—as many Second Wave feminists and our Christian and conservative allies once did.
No, I do not think that hiding women beneath burqas is, therefore, any kind of solution. In fact, both pornography and prostitution are booming businesses in most Muslim countries.
Before we go any further, let’s play twenty questions. I really want your answers.
1. Is pornography “work” or is it a violent crime?
2. Is pornography “free speech” in action or is it a violent, often murderous crime?
3. Is pornography really a “victimless” crime?
4. Are pimps, johns, traffickers, and landlords being victimized? If so, why are they not complaining?
5. Are the people, mainly men, who buy and watch pornography being victimized? If so, why are they not complaining? Is anyone forcing them to consume pornography?
6. Are the seductive, taunting, smiling, naked girls and women who are being paid “good” money–victims? If so, why don’t they complain, leave, find some other job?
7. Isn’t working in pornography a job just like any other job–like any other acting job?
8. Aren’t pornography actors there of their own free will—for the easy money, the attention, the “stardom?”
9. Isn’t our right to see and read whatever interests us essential to our fundamental liberty?
10. Doesn’t the First Amendment guarantee us this right? If we criminalize one kind of “free speech,” where will it end? Who will decide what information or images we are allowed to see? Won’t state or religious censorship chill our rights, even our very thoughts?
11. On behalf of “free speech,” and privacy rights, didn’t Second Wave feminists avidly collaborate with pornographers to ensure that pornography remained a civil right?
12. Didn’t Second Wave feminists launch the battle against violence against women, which included sexual harassment, rape, incest, domestic battering—as well as the most serious battle against pornography and prostitution? Weren’t they vilified for collaborating with Christians and conservatives on the issue of pornography and prostitution?
13. How many women from wealthy and prominent families, or with advanced educations, “choose” to work in pornography or as prostitutes?
14. Did you know that, by definition, pornography is that which has to do with “prostitutes.” “Porne” in Greek is a “prostitute.” The so-called actresses in pornography are treated as if they are–and usually soon are–also “working” as prostitutes.
15. How different is being a prostitute from being a stripper, massage therapist, or a nurse?
16. How many prostituted girls and women are actually free to leave, walk out, give it all up?
17. Where might they go? Where might they call “home?” Who will help them get off drugs and alcohol, restore their ravaged health, support them as they deal with the sexually transmitted diseases, including AIDS, with which johns have infected them?
18. Do you have any idea of what the average age of a pornography actress/prostitute is?
19. How long a shelf-life does a “working girl” (prostitute, pornography actress) actually have?
20. Why does pornography “turn” people on?
I lived through the great feminist Sex Wars. I was both a participant and an eye-witness, as well as a confidante to feminists who were on both sides of this War. But before I share memories and analysis, I really want to hear from you. Your answers will help me understand how to share a vast body of knowledge and history with you in the most productive way. Here’s a hint to help you think through these questions.
Pornography is a multi-billion dollar industry, right up there with guns and drugs. It is enormously profitable but not to the “workers,” most of whom are girls and women who have been sold by their parents, captured in war, kidnapped off the street, forced by their husbands, or who have been driven by poverty, racism, incest, and the most violent sexism into the arms of pimps, traffickers, landlords, advertisers, law enforcement officers, and johns.
Phyllis Chesler, Ph.D is an Emerita Professor of Psychology and Women's Studies at City University of New York. She is an author, psychotherapist and an expert courtroom witness. She has lectured and organized political, legal, religious and human rights campaigns in the United States and in Canada, Europe, the Middle East and the Far East. A popular guest on campuses and in national and international print, television, radio and online media, she has been an expert commentator on the major events of our time. She has lived in Kabul, Afghanistan, and in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. She currently resides in Manhattan.
The questions are so leading, and clearly presented from the “anti” perspective that no reasonable findings could be made.
Don’t get me wrong—I am not into porno, and I think the points made in the intro are close to my own feelings.
However, many of these questions are akin to “when did you stop beating your wife.”
There’s a different between freedom and approbation. Porn isn’t a good thing for the people who work in it.
Yes, freedom permits them to engage in that activity, and there will always be a market for that activity, but how many of you would want your daughters to be engaged in that activity?
. Are the people, mainly men, who buy and watch pornography being victimized
Really? You actually believe this?
You need to do some research amongst the women folk.
She would not have any "issues" over men preferring to look at women who are younger and hotter than her. Of course not.
Ummm, “industry?”
Way too many questions if she really wants a response. I am sure she already has her idea of what each answer is supposed to be and there for has her “plan of attack” all laid out.
As the father of a lot of girls I will say this. You have to give your girls attention. My 13 yo likes to watch Kendra,(yeah I am a horrible parent/s). I like to make fun of Kendra so it works out. I tell her time and time again that for every Kendra there are thousands of other girls who have real world problems that you don’t want any part of.
I don’t think telling grown men or women that pornography is bad is going to help one stinking bit. I don’t think any amount of guilt trip is going to change their minds. It really begins at home. The users of pornography are not going to change so we need to stem the tide of girls willing to sell their bodies for a few bucks.
Jewish psychologist. Jewish American Princess.....
I think I’ve been on FR too long...as I scrolled through your post I thought “this must be that Lazamataz guy”. I got to the tagline and I was right!
That alone got me laughing (so did your post).
They had 20 questions about pornography, so I gave 'em 20 answers.
All legislation is legislating morality. The only question is are wee going to legislate the morality of traditional Christian America or that of Hustler. To date Hustler is winning hands down.
The upper house of the Swiss Parliament is considering a bill to do away with laws against incest, as long as both partners are consenting adults.
I do not approve. I would like to see porno criminalized, starting with production and distribution. Making porno is
Prostitution.
There’s no force like Wilberforce.
All legislation is legislating morality. The only question is are wee going to legislate the morality of traditional Christian America or that of Hustler. To date Hustler is winning hands down.
The upper house of the Swiss Parliament is considering a bill to do away with laws against incest, as long as both partners are consenting adults.
I do not approve. I would like to see porno criminalized, starting with production and distribution. Making porno is
Prostitution.
It makes my stecker piff.
I break out in hands.
So much info that most of us probably didn’t want to know.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.