[tobyhill]

The rankings all year long are based on “prettier” wins except for the last game. Why should Texas deserve it more than TCU, Boise State or even Cincinnati?

[Nervous Tick]

You’re not grasping the concept here.

[dfwgator]

That’s why my idea is that in the following regular season, every BCS team has to play two games against other BCS teams. Now it’s not perfect, in that from year-to-year, teams will drop off due to graduation, but in the absence of a playoff, it will provide a way for good teams to play each other.

[ColdWater]

The rankings all year long are based on “prettier” wins except for the last game. Why should Texas deserve it more than TCU, Boise State or even Cincinnati?

Perhaps because TCU didn't play any good teams?

[OrangeHoof]

Why should Texas deserve it more than TCU, Boise State or even Cincinnati?

They don't. That's why I favor and eight-team playoff where all of it could be settled on the field. If my plan was in place, we would have this entree on December 19: 9) Georgia Tech at 1) Alabama 8) Ohio State at 2) Texas 7) Oregon at 3) Cincinnati 6) Boise St. at 4) TCU Semifinals would part of the New Years bowls and the Chamiponship Game would be in mid-January. (If you're wondering where Florida is in the playoff - they're out because didn't win their conference. The rest did and that's the key to qualifying for the playoff).