Posted on 11/01/2008 8:16:36 AM PDT by smoothsailing
BY MIKE FAHER
The Tribune-Democrat
November 01, 2008 12:01 am
—
It would have been considered unthinkable just a few weeks ago: U.S. Rep. John Murtha, a 17-term congressional stalwart, forced to fight for his political life.
But that’s what appears to be happening just days before 12th district voters decide whether to send the powerful Johnstown Democrat back to Washington.
In the past week, Murtha’s campaign has shifted from cruise control to top speed in the face of a surprisingly strong challenge from Republican opponent William Russell.
And while polling data are scarce, it is clear that the veteran congressman and his supporters – both locally and nationally – are concerned.
“I got blindsided,” Murtha acknowledged Friday after an event at Pitt-Johnstown.
“I should never have waited as long (to campaign) as I did,” he said. “I just thought nobody would vote for a guy who has never lived in this district.”
For most of this year, the 12th district race – pitting Murtha against a political newcomer who moved here to challenge the incumbent – was attracting no attention from election operatives or the national press.
But that changed in mid-October, when Murtha called western Pennsylvania a “racist area” and later used the term “redneck” to describe his district’s history – both during media interviews.
The controversy prompted a Murtha apology, but also spurred a Murtha parody on NBC’s “Saturday Night Live.”
Whether those comments have led directly to the significant tightening of this race is up for debate. Russell has for months attempted to paint his opponent as an out-of-touch liberal, leaning heavily on Murtha’s opposition to the war in Iraq.
“Our internal (polling) showed three weeks ago that this was a race – even before Jack called his constituents racist,” said Peg Luksik, Russell’s campaign manager.
‘It is urgent’
Still, it is clear that the last seven to 10 days have dramatically changed the tenor of the race:
• On Oct. 23, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review reported that a poll conducted for the newspaper showed Murtha with only a four-point lead, within the survey’s margin of error.
• On Oct. 25, Murtha’s campaign sent its first press release attacking Russell directly. Several more were issued over the following days.
• Financial contributions to Murtha’s campaign – which had lagged behind Russell in fund- raising and spending – in-creased dramatically in the past seven days.
• Murtha advertisements have been running frequently on local TV stations and are appearing in this newspaper this weekend.
Forms filed with the Federal Election Commission show Murtha having raised $570,750 this week. And those reports account only for donations of $1,000 or more.
In contrast, Murtha reported $457,340 in contributions from July 1 through Sept. 30.
The Hill, a Washington newspaper, on Thursday reported that Murtha “has sent out a last-minute plea for $1 million to save his hotly contested seat.”
And on Wednesday, Murtha put out a fundraising plea to members of the liberal group MoveOn.org.
“When I ask for help, it is because I really need it,” he wrote. “It is urgent.”
‘Helping with advertising’
To further highlight that sense of urgency, national political groups this week made their presence felt in the 12th district race for the first time.
Sensing Murtha’s vulnerability, the National Republican Congressional Committee went on the attack with television ads.
“After four decades in Congress, John Murtha has grown out of touch,” said Ken Spain, the GOP congressional committee’s spokesman.
“By calling his own constituents racists and rednecks, he has brought national embarrassment upon himself and to the district he claims to represent.”
Meanwhile, a campaign organization representing House Democrats bought television time to defend Murtha. And state Democrats also are chipping in.
“We’re helping with advertising, we’re helping with mailers,” said Abe Amoros, state Democratic Party spokesman.
As they did in 2006, when Murtha’s Iraq stance led to a relatively tough re-election campaign, fellow Democratic politicians are stepping forward to back the congressman.
Pennsylvania Auditor General Jack Wagner called The Tribune-Democrat this week to offer his support. Wagner, along with Democratic U.S. Sen. Bob Casey, is scheduled to appear in Johnstown today at a 9:45 a.m. rally for the congressman at 647 Main St.
Wagner, who like Murtha is a Vietnam veteran, said he has supported the congressman since his first campaign in 1974.
“Pennsylvania, especially western Pennsylvania, doesn’t have a more effective person in government than Congressman Murtha,” Wagner said.
‘We feel ... confident’
As it became clear this week that Murtha had a fight on his hands, many local leaders have expressed similar sentiments.
For the most part, they are effusively praising Murtha’s well-documented ability to bring cash and jobs to the district.
“He has led us to a diverse economy, a vibrant economy,” said P.J. Stevens, Cambria County president commissioner.
“And going forward, nobody is in a better position than the congressman to see that the growth continues.”
On Friday, Murtha received Pitt-Johnstown’s distinguished alumni award. In a speech at the ceremony, university President Jem Spectar discussed the congressman’s support for the educational system.
Amoros said Democrats believe Murtha’s constituents are “more worried about their pocketbooks” than the congressman’s recent controversies.
“We feel quite confident that, at the end of the day on Tuesday, Jack Murtha will be re-elected,” he said.
But where some see a temporary aberration, Russell’s supporters believe they’re witnessing a sea change.
“If you disconnect from the people you represent,” Luksik said, “eventually they’re going to notice.”
Copyright © 1999-2008 cnhi, inc.
Photos
Congressman John Murtha speaks about what the new Tech Park means to the Greater Johnstown Community, Thursday October 30. The Tribune-Democrat
Candidate William Russell
If Murtha wins the people in that district can go to Hell
Extrememly extreme dittos to that comment! People must be held responsible for their actions and voting for Murtha makes one deserving of naught but scorn and loathing.
Murtha voter: “Where am I going? And why am I in this handbasket?”
Goodbye Murtha you commie POS!
BTTT
ping
Those Americans in PA bear the responsibility of looking the other way.
So he thought he was immune.
They thought they were immune, too.
An important lesson I learned from a good black preacher:
If you hang out in the pigsty, you start smelling like the pigs.
..begin to see their constituency as rednecks...etc...
== = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = == = = = = = =
I had always thought the term redneck was attributed to the ‘stoop’ laborers whose neck and arms were darkened due to the exposure to the elements while working in various forms of the construction and agriculture fields.
Hence IMNSHO redneck means Hard Working, Middle Class.
After reading Wikipedia’s description I see it further traces back to Scots and Northern Irish that came to this country and settled in the Appalachians and South etc....
Now with that ‘definition’ doesn’t calling ‘poor whites’ rednecks fall in the same vein as calling Black People N.....s?
The wikipedia def also refers to rednecks/poor white trash in their summation.....
Rednecks now are folks that work hard, don’t blame others for their predicament, and cling to guns and religion. ;)
But its funny with Murtha. He certainly could say without raising an eyebrow “We Rednecks”. But when he doesn’t place himself in that group anymore, he slanders them. He can’t represent his constituency any more.
In 2006, 60% of those voters put Murtha in office, 40% were disgusted with him and voted for Diana Irey.
This time, even more of us are disgusted,and the goal is to make sure it's more than 50% who vote for Russell.
Whatever the outcome, those who support Murtha will always be seen by me this way....
Quite appropriate : )
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.