245(i) is hardly "amnesty" - or there would hardly be such a huge population of illegals now here, a very high share of whom were here when 245(i) ended last spring!
Most illegals - Mexican border-skippers - just don't legally qualify for 245(i). They lack the required family ties.
History proves that 245(i) is a boon for Asian grad students who overstay student visas and marry some dumb American - not for Mexican border-skippers lacking both the $1,000 fee and the dumb gringa wife.
IMMIGRATION resource library - with public-health facts of immigration!
The family ties provision in the bill helps, but when these families include as many as ten or more children ...
I agree with the gist of what you wrote 10000%, but that last comment was over the top.