Posted on 07/15/2003 7:59:29 AM PDT by Pyro7480
SSPX
Question from Anne on 07-10-2003:
Dear Fr. Levis,
Thanks so much for the work you do on this forum. I love reading Catholic Q&A, and you are my favorite expert.
Ive read quite a few postings on the SSPX lately, some of them regarding the possibility of their joining full communion with the Church. Some people have seemed interested in joining because they're fed up with abuses some priests and bishops do in the Novus Ordo. I belonged to an independent church, then the SSPX for 19 years, and through the grace of God am back in communion with Rome. The SSPX does not believe the Novus Ordo mass is valid. My brother still belongs to the SSPX and was ordered by his priest to decline the invitation to be a groomsman in our wedding because of the invalidity of the mass. They are a cult, with the Archbishop Fellay holding the same power as the Pope in the eyes of their followers, though they will adamantly deny both of these facts. In many ways the SSPX holds a Cafeteria Catholic view, in that they pick and choose which teachings of the Pope fit their agenda. They claim they are only keeping tradition alive, and will merge back with the Church once the Pope comes to his senses, nullifies the Novus Ordo and reinstitutes the Latin Mass. This is simply not true even if this were ever to happen, because the bishops do not want to lose the power they hold over their flock, and although they claim they are only keeping the Latin Mass alive, they have made many new laws of their own. An example: My brother was not allowed to propose to his fiancé until he had his engagement blessed because his priest told him to break off an engagement is a mortal sin. Many priests in the SSPX also teach that Natural Family Planning is sinful because they claim it leads to contraception. They keep a tight grasp on their people, and as is typical of many cults, attempt to control almost every aspect of their lives. So many people suffer from scruples due to the over-pious fanaticism taught. The SSPX can be very appealing to those who love the Tridentine Mass, but they are wolves in sheeps clothing. Many dioceses offer Indult Masses (which the SSPX claim is a step down because the priest saying the mass compromises). So if you love the Tridentine Mass, find an indult mass, but stay FAR FAR away from the SSPX!
Thanks and God Bless
Anne
Answer by Fr. Robert J. Levis on 07-11-2003:
Dear Anne, A wonderful story of your journey to a healthy Catholic life in a hectic time! Yes, what you say of the SSPX is true. Unfortunately as it grows older, more and more heresies will find their way in and the poor people will be led astray. Yes, keep them all in your good prayers. God bless you. Fr Bob Levis
Lo: I'm not judging the SSPX and consider attendees to be fellow Catholics. Right now, I feel called to work for restoration "from within".
I need a little clarification. I was under the impression that for the Latin Rite all Priests were to know and be able to say Mass in Latin, Latin being the normative language for the Latin Rite. Permission from the Bishop is then needed to say Mass in the venacular (approved texts), not the Latin. This refers to the Order of the Mass approved by Pope Paul VI ("Novus Ordo").
An indult was given by the Pope to allow for use of the "Tridentine" Rite, with certain conditions attached, with the statement that he hoped it would be given wide and generous application by the Bishops. Conditions include that those using it recognize the validity of Vatican II. However, indults are contigent on the local Ordinary giving permission for it's use.
Is this correct?
My comment, though, was based on the pope's direction to the bishops in Ecclesia Dei for a "wide and generous" allowance for the old Mass. Longshanks said his bishop is disobeying that, and not allowing any Latin masses (by which I assume he means the Tridentine, not the Lating Novus Ordo).
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.