[NYer]

The guidelines don't mention punishment _ such as excommunication _ for Catholic politicians who fail to tow the line. Rather, they frame the issue as one of ``conscience'' that politicians will have to deal with.

Another example of "catholic lite". How disappointing!

[Desdemona]

In way, though, this is good. Catholics will be more prone to hold some politician's feet to the fire. It's not going to happen overnight.

I am disappointed that Archbishop Gregory is having trouble finding HIS spine, but the Lord obviously has a plan.

[.45MAN]

Well maybe a little disapointing but we as faithful can also push the issue. Holding back the weekly offering and demanding that things be done is in our power....

[SuziQ]

Another example of "catholic lite". How disappointing!

It might be more a case of an iron fist in a velvet glove. It might give those Catholic politicians some pause and make them think about the final results of their votes.

If the Vatican had come out directly with an 'excommunication' notice, don't you think those same politicians would have immediately gotten their backs up and taken the attitude "They can't tell ME what to do!" It is human nature to not want to be controlled. I believe The Vatican understands this, and wants to 'enlighten' those folks rather than turn them right off!