Posted on 11/18/2026 4:30:45 PM PST by ebb tide

In the statement issued by the Dicastery for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments following the ad limina visit of the Panamanian Episcopal Conference, held on October 21, 2026, in the presence of the controversial Cardinal Arthur Roche, an explicit warning emerged against “extremism in the liturgical sphere.”
What could this possibly refer to? The ongoing liturgical abuses committed during Eucharistic celebrations? The “creative” priests who spontaneously invent phrases and gestures absent from the Missal? The bishops who celebrate Mass wearing bandanas, bathing suits, or who instruct the congregation to recite the Creed silently so as not to offend any non-Christians who might happen to be present in the church? None of the above.
Here is what the document states: “The dialogue also brought to light the danger of extremism in the liturgical sphere and of the instrumentalization of the Eucharistic celebration by certain groups of the faithful. These groups tend to provoke division and confusion by raising issues such as receiving Communion kneeling and in the hand, or the use of the veil by women. It was reaffirmed that the Eucharist is the sacrament of unity and cannot become an object of contention.”
Both practices belong to the Church’s perennial Tradition and centuries-old discipline, whereas the actual rupture was caused by the liturgical reforms and derogations introduced in the post-conciliar period.Tweet this quote
These, then, are the problems that supposedly threaten the proper celebration of Mass today, according to Roche and his associates! Labeling Communion received kneeling and the use of the women’s veil as divisive issues and, at least implicitly, as ideological innovations introduced by individual groups amounts to a complete reversal of historical and theological reality. Both practices belong to the Church’s perennial Tradition and centuries-old discipline, whereas the actual rupture was caused by the liturgical reforms and derogations introduced in the post-conciliar period, that is, over the past sixty years.
The Eucharist is undoubtedly the sacrament of unity. The question is what is meant by “unity.” Authentic Catholic unity is not founded on a sociological compromise whereby all personal preferences are acceptable, but on the integral profession of the Faith and the supreme worship of adoration due to Jesus Christ. Unity is an essential component of truth, as well as one of its effects at the social level. The real danger of division does not come from those who kneel before the Divine Majesty, but from those who weaken faith in the Real Presence, reducing the Holy Sacrifice of Calvary to a mere banquet or community celebration.
To understand the doctrinal significance of receiving Communion on the tongue and kneeling, as opposed to the handling of the Host by laypeople, we must go back to the origins of modern regulations. When the practice of distributing Communion in the hand began to spread abusively after the Second Vatican Council, Pope Paul VI consulted the world’s episcopate through the instruction Memoriale Domini (1969).
An overwhelming majority of bishops (1,233 opposed, compared with 567 in favor) firmly rejected the introduction of this innovation. Nevertheless, the Holy See, and especially the episcopal conferences, granted indults, that is, temporary derogations, which soon transformed the exception into a de facto universal norm. This is a typical neo-modernist practice: introducing exceptions, allowing derogations without clearly defined limits, approving indults without valid reasons but which nonetheless suit the prevailing mentality, and which gradually supplant the hated Traditional practice without officially changing the norm.
The normalization of the indult was accompanied by an attempt at theological justification. Thus, within Catholic circles, one encounters various pseudo-arguments in favor of Communion in the hand. Its supporters claim that in the early centuries the faithful normally received the Eucharist in their hands. For this reason, Communion in the hand would supposedly represent a recovery of an older practice. This, however, is false and rests on malicious interpretations of patristic passages.
The most famous is a passage by St. Cyril of Jerusalem, who writes that the faithful should receive the Host with their hands prepared “as a throne.” What is left unspecified is that St. Cyril celebrated according to the fourth-century Jerusalem Rite, from which various Eastern rites would subsequently derive. We are therefore speaking neither of today’s Roman Rite nor of medieval Latin liturgy. The Eucharistic reverence required by that Rite is not even comparable to the carelessness of today’s celebrations. Moreover, the consecrated Host was often received in the hand using the dominicale, a sort of veil or white cloth that prevented direct contact with the Eucharist. It is also interesting to note that St. Cyril’s text itself places the strongest possible emphasis on not losing even a single particle of the consecrated Host.
The Eucharist is undoubtedly the sacrament of unity. The question is what is meant by ‘unity.’Tweet this quote
Furthermore, “Traditional” does not mean “older,” and “older” does not necessarily mean “better.” Liturgical archaeologism is a widespread error consisting in considering a practice preferable simply because it is older. This tendency, moreover, bears considerable similarities to the Protestant approach, which tends to set the primitive Church against the subsequent developments of Tradition. Catholic theology, by contrast, recognizes the value of the organic development of Tradition, which, let us be clear, deepens the Mystery of Faith not in the sense that it “evolves” by passing from one form to another, different or even opposed, but in the sense that it “grows,” just as a human being passes from childhood to adulthood while remaining the very same person.
For this reason, the mere fact that a particular practice was attested in the early centuries is not in itself sufficient to demonstrate that it is superior to the subsequent developments that matured within the life of the Church.
Indeed, historically, Communion in the hand did not originate in ancient patristic practice, but was introduced by Martin Luther (after having disappeared from the Latin Church for over a millennium) with the explicit aim of denying transubstantiation and the propitiatory value of the Mass. If the Mass is the unbloody renewal of the Sacrifice of Calvary, the Divine Victim must be truly present and adored.
If, instead, it is reduced to a mere “friendly dinner” or a simple narrative, a communal remembrance of the Last Supper, then the introduction of bread taken in the hand and of the priest facing the congregation like an ordinary master of ceremonies at a dining table becomes understandable. Indeed, judging by statistics, we know that the number of Catholics who do not believe in the Real Presence today is far from insignificant.
Above all, each of us can see how, every Sunday, the lines of Catholics receiving Communion are far longer than those of Catholics going to confession (assuming one can even easily find a confessor before Mass): the numbers simply do not add up.
As if that were not enough, the Dicastery’s warning directly contradicts the Code of Canon Law and the Church’s recent Magisterium. The instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum (2004, nos. 91–92) formally establishes that no priest may refuse Holy Communion to a member of the faithful solely because he wishes to receive it kneeling and on the tongue. It is therefore seriously contradictory to define as “extremist” or a “source of confusion” gestures that Rome itself guarantees and recommends. Rather, these bishops and cardinals create confusion and scandal among the faithful by encouraging such abuses.
The reasons why a properly instructed Catholic should always, exclusively and under all circumstances receive the Eucharist on the tongue, if possible while kneeling, and never in the hands, are readily stated.
Since under the species of bread and wine Christ is wholly present in Body, Blood, Soul, and Divinity (cf. Summa Theologiae III, q. 75, a. 5; q. 76, a. 8), the Eucharist is due the worship of absolute adoration, superior even to the veneration reserved for the Blessed Virgin Mary and the Saints. The act of receiving the Host on the tongue and kneeling is the indispensable bodily expression of this Faith.
St. Thomas also explains that, during the Last Supper, Christ first received the Eucharist and then distributed it to the Apostles (S.Th. III, q. 81, a. 1); and in doing so, Judas Iscariot also received the Eucharist (S.Th. III, q. 81, a. 2). However, this is not an argument in favor of the permissibility of receiving Communion in a state of mortal sin: Jesus did not publicly exclude Judas because he was a hidden sinner, but for Judas it was a most grave sacrilege to approach in a state of mortal guilt (cf. S.Th. III, q. 80, a. 4).
Some use the argument of the “morsel dipped and given to Judas” (cf. John 13:21–30) to support the practice of Communion in the hand, but this argument is fallacious for two reasons. First, because it was precisely a “morsel” (in Greek: psōmíon; Latin: buccella), meaning that Jesus placed the “dipped” bread directly into Judas’ mouth; second, the Fathers teach that this morsel was not the Eucharist, but ordinary bread offered after the distribution of the sacrament (cf. S.Th. III, q. 81, a. 2, ad 3).
St. Thomas Aquinas also teaches that the handling and distribution of the Sacred Species belong by their proper right exclusively to the priest (cf. S.Th. III, q. 82, a. 3), who acts in persona Christi and whose hands are anointed through the Sacrament of Holy Orders. Indeed, even sacred vessels should be handled only by the priest, to the extent that prohibiting laypeople from accessing them has always been the practice. Reducing the handling of the Host to a lay gesture means obscuring the ministerial priesthood in favor of the common priesthood of the faithful.
Finally, since Christ is wholly and entirely present in every single fragment of consecrated bread, the Church always prescribed the use of the paten and the utmost care to prevent the loss of particles and offenses against the Sacrament (cf. S.Th. III, q. 80, a. 12). Communion in the hand inevitably exposes the Eucharist to the scattering of fragments and the risk of appalling profanations, and this happens regularly in our churches: it is no secret that many people (even Satanists) approach Communion in order to steal the Hosts and use them in blasphemous acts.
If this were not sufficiently clear, in light of all this it is appropriate to ask whether – despite what many bishops and cardinals preach – receiving Communion in the hand is truly free from grave matter (specifically, the sin of sacrilege), given what the Church, the saints, and the Doctors have always taught (cf. S.Th. III, q. 80, a. 4).
The real danger of division does not come from those who kneel before the Divine Majesty, but from those who weaken faith in the Real Presence.Tweet this quote
Rather curiously, neo-modernists justify their hostility toward the women’s veil with arguments that mirror those used against receiving Communion kneeling and on the tongue. If, in the latter case, it is argued that Communion in the hand is preferable because it is closer to the practice of the primitive Church, when it comes to the women’s veil – which, unlike the former, is undoubtedly attested from the Apostolic Age onward – the opposite argument is invoked: namely, that “times changed.”
The same applies to other ancient customs now considered unacceptable, such as the separation of men and women during liturgical functions (cf. Canon 1262 § 1 of the 1917 Code) or penitential discipline. This demonstrates how liturgical archaeologism is employed selectively and ideologically: it is invoked when it allows the established Catholic Tradition to be called into question, but immediately discarded when ancient practices prove inconvenient to contemporary sensibilities.
In any case, the question of the liturgical veil belongs to a different category from the question of how to receive Holy Communion. While the latter, as we have seen, involves grave matter, the failure to use the veil does not.
Viewed from a worldly perspective, external to the Catholic faith, the act of women covering their heads with a veil in church may appear to be an incomprehensible anachronism or a regressive imposition. However, to understand the true meaning of this gesture, one must free oneself from contemporary prejudices and explore its actual anthropological, theological, and historical nature.
First, it must be remembered that the use of the liturgical veil is rooted in Sacred Scripture (cf. 1 Corinthians 11:3-16) and in the practice of the first centuries of the Church, codified as early as the pontificate of Pope St. Linus [+ AD 80].
It is essential to clarify a fundamental point for those unfamiliar with Canon law. Catholic theology teaches that there are two parts of law: one of divine origin, which is irreformable, and one human, which is reformable. Within human ecclesiastical law, which serves divine law, one can further identify what is known as apostolic law, which belongs primarily to the liturgical sphere.
Although apostolic law is in itself reformable, since it is human law, the Church always refrained from changing it, to the extent that some canonists in the past hypothesized that a Pope who modified apostolic law could even be accused of being a “schismatic Pope.”
The liturgical veil for women belongs precisely to apostolic law. It is a custom that the Church preserved throughout the centuries because of its profound symbolic and pedagogical value, as is typical of everything concerning the liturgy. The 1917 Code of Canon Law went so far as to regulate its use: “Men in church or outside the church, while attending sacred rites, shall remain bareheaded…; women, on the other hand, shall have their heads covered and dress modestly, especially when approaching the Lord’s table” (Canon 1262 § 2).
It is therefore seriously contradictory to define as ‘extremist’ or a ‘source of confusion’ gestures that Rome itself guarantees and recommends.Tweet this quote
However, from a strictly penal point of view, the 1917 Code did not provide for any formal canonical sanction or penalty for those who did not wear the veil. Practical enforcement was left to the supervision of parish priests, who had the duty to admonish or, at most, advise and instruct the faithful. The new 1983 Code, by contrast, omitted this custom entirely, effectively abrogating it and downgrading it to a kind of “private and optional devotional practice.”
Despite this, the women’s veil possesses a rich theological symbolism. A woman is called to cover her hair in church because hair has traditionally been a symbol of glory and beauty. Glory, in fact, is defined as the manifestation of one’s own sovereignty. In Sacred Scripture, hair is often used as a symbol of divine glory in the human person and, therefore, as a symbol of dignity. This is because dignity is the source of rights, but the source of dignity is God’s Kingship.
This symbolism applies not only to women’s hair, but also to men’s hair. The most famous biblical example is undoubtedly that of Samson (cf. Judges 13-16). The angel announced to his mother: “No razor shall touch his head, for the boy shall be a Nazirite consecrated to God from his mother’s womb” (13:5). Hair is obviously not the cause of Samson’s strength – his strength comes from God – but it becomes the outward sign of his consecration and dignity, which the Lord raised above that of the other Israelites: the strength of the spirit is thus manifested through the strength of the body.
The gesture of wearing the veil is viewed with suspicion today not only because modern thought is essentially androgynous, and deeply hostile to the differentiation of sexual roles, but also because it is radically anti-hierarchical.
The Church always taught that the family, like every society worthy of the name, is hierarchical. Speaking of glory, St. Paul writes that “a man ought not to cover his head, since he is the image and glory of God, but woman is the glory of man” (1 Corinthians 11:7). We will not dwell here on the reasons for this hierarchical relationship.
Suffice it to say that Traditional doctrine holds that man and woman share equal ontological dignity insofar as they are created in the image of God, while at the same time affirming a relational hierarchy of divine and natural law, in which man is called to be the head and ordering principle of the family, and woman its foundation of guidance and counsel. This order, distorted by original sin (cf. Genesis 3:17), is ultimately made explicit and normative by God as a providential remedy for the protection of human society. Ubi amor deficit, lex necesse est.
St. Paul begins from this revealed fact and draws upon the biblical symbolism of hair when he prescribes: “Her hair has been given to her for a covering” (vv. 14–15). The Greek word used by the Apostle to the Gentiles is peribòlaion, which literally means “a covering object.” St. Jerome translates it into Latin as velamen, “veil,” which might prompt the reader to raise the following question: if hair is already a veil, why cover one veil with another veil?
The apparent contradiction disappears once one understands that Paul’s argument takes place within a strictly liturgical symbolic context, but his premises are rooted in anthropology, that is, in the very nature of the human being. Indeed, immediately beforehand, the Apostle wrote: “Does not nature itself teach you that it is disgraceful for a man to wear his hair long, but that it is a glory for a woman to wear her hair long?” (v. 14).
God’s glory, that is, the manifestation of His power, is not manifested in woman in the same way as in man. The supreme manifestation of divine glory in man, in fact, is found in the priesthood. In woman, by contrast, it is found in motherhood. Both bring forth life: the former to supernatural life, the latter to natural life. By her very nature, woman is more closely connected to corporeality than man. For this reason, the female body is, in a certain sense, “more sacred” than the male body, because it is predisposed to generating life in the biological and natural sense.
Long hair is like a veil because it envelops and frames the face, that is, female identity. In the Bible, the face is a symbol, but also an “indication,” of one’s identity (cf. Matthew 6:22–23) and of the divine presence in man. Moreover, from the perspective of the ancients, covering does not mean denying or despising, but, on the contrary, recognizing value. In women’s hair, which tends to be longer than men’s, the ancients saw a sign of the sacredness of the body and face, that is, of female identity.
The more precious something is, the more we tend to safeguard it.Tweet this quote
Unveiling, by contrast, means denying and profaning. Consider also the sin of Ham (cf. Genesis 9:20–27). Contemporary society reversed this meaning, so that uncovering the female body is now understood as enhancing its value. And yet, in many other areas, we behave differently. The things we care about most are also those we are most inclined to protect and shield from indiscreet eyes: our affections, so-called “sensitive” data, family heirlooms. No one leaves a safe open in order to enhance the value of its contents; no one publishes their bank account codes online to demonstrate their importance; no one displays on the street the most intimate letters received from loved ones. A valuable gift is wrapped, a fragile object is protected, a precious ring is kept in a jewelry box. Even photographs of our children or the most personal moments of family life are reserved for a limited circle of people. Not because we are ashamed of them, but precisely because we consider them too important to be exposed indiscriminately. The more precious something is, the more we tend to safeguard it. The symbolic boundary between private and public is instinctive, deeply rooted in our soul, and facts often contradict the most common beliefs and statements.
Today we have forgotten the difference between what is “gratuitous” and what is “irrelevant,” confusing the two. When something is offered because the recipient cannot afford it despite needing it, that thing is gratuitous: the exemplary case is God’s Grace. When something is given not because the recipient cannot afford it or needs it, but because it is of little value in the eyes of the giver (and therefore the giving-interest lies with the giver, not the recipient), then that thing is irrelevant.
This is the underlying problem: today it has become normal to offer one’s own body to everyone’s gaze because one’s body is considered to be of little value compared with what one hopes to obtain in return, namely approval, the acceptance of others, often the resolution of one’s own unresolved sexuality. This is why Scripture warns: “Charm is deceptive and beauty is fleeting; but a woman who fears the Lord is to be praised” (Proverbs 31:30).
If hair reminds a woman to safeguard her own corporeality, the liturgical veil is a “veil over the veil,” that is, it invites her to cover human glory before God during the liturgy, because God’s glory is greater. In a certain sense, the women’s veil reminds human being of his proper place before God. This is why St. Paul writes that a woman covers herself while praying “because of the angels” (v. 10).
In biblical language, angels are particularly present during liturgical functions. Now, St. Thomas Aquinas emphasizes that, during Mass, angels are invisibly present and offer continuous adoration to the Divine Majesty. Therefore, the veiled woman manifests, recalls, and acknowledges the real presence of God, before whom even the angels humble themselves.
There is a further argument in favor of the liturgical veil, and it comes from Marian apparitions. Mary often appears adapting herself to the culture of the visionary (at Guadalupe she appeared as an Amerindian girl, at Lourdes she spoke in the local dialect, at La Salette she appeared wearing traditional pastoral clothing), but always wearing a veil. Surely this must mean something.
The average woman, even a Catholic woman, unaccustomed to thinking in symbols as was typical of the ancients and of Christians themselves until the early modern age, tends to reinterpret these gestures through modern categories and ideological lenses, and therefore reduces everything to the Marxist and revolutionary interpretation according to which history is an inevitable succession of struggles. In this case, the veil would supposedly be a sign of the struggle that patriarchy waged against women and of their consequent subjugation.
As we have seen so far, this is not the case at all. The veil is a symbol of the immense value of the female body, as well as of divine glory and of the dignity of the human genus, which are manifested in a privileged way in the female gender, insofar as it is biologically predisposed to generate and nurse life.
Finally, the ever-increasing presence of Islamic culture in our Western societies and the false belief (now widespread even among Catholics) that Islam is merely one religion among many, indeed even the “third monotheistic religion,” also leads Catholics to develop distorted views of reality. Since the time of the Church Fathers (consider St. John of Damascus), Islam has rightly been classified not as a new revelation, but as a heresy of Christianity.
Several doctrinal errors from the early centuries converge within it, primarily errors proper to Arianism, Docetism, and above all Ebionism, that is, a strongly “Judaized” and legalistic conception of religious life.
From Ebionism, Islam inherited the primacy of orthopraxy over orthodoxy and of external discipline over interior life. The relationship with God is reduced to the mechanical observance of a legal code. By virtue of this heretical imprint, many religious customs of Christians in the early centuries were adopted and inadequately filtered into the Arab-Islamic world. However, having been uprooted from their theological context and, above all, from liturgical life, these practices underwent a radical degeneration: symbols were crystallized into prescriptions.
The hijab and the burqa constitute the legalistic degeneration of the Christian veil. Women are covered not because their bodies are a sacred mystery to be reserved for God and their husbands, but because they are considered inherently a source of disorder (fitna) and of uncontrollable carnal temptation for men. In the same way, the machismo of Islamic society represents the perverse caricature of Catholic Patriarchy.
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
One does not need a veil one can wear a hat.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.