Posted on 08/21/2023 3:52:45 PM PDT by Morgana
Christianity Today has truly outdone itself by stringing together the so-called “epic trifecta” of Greta Gerwig’s Barbie, Beyoncé’s Renaissance Tour, and Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour into a fanciful tale of cultural enlightenment. If we are to believe this narrative, these pop culture phenomenons are not just grand entertainments but profound spiritual experiences that open up dialogues about female angst and communal meaning. It’s a thesis that’s more fitting for a teen magazine than a serious Christian publication, as it suggests in an article it recently published that the likes of Barbie and Swift are leading a “seismic shift for women” and bridging the gap between the Church and the world. Actual headline from Christianity Today article…
The insidious creep of cultural Marxism, feminist ideologies, and intersectionality into the very core of Christian dialogue cannot be ignored. When a publication like Christianity Today produces an article equating the likes of Barbie, Beyoncé, and Taylor Swift with meaningful theological discourse, we have reached a zenith of absurdity. To say that this approach is incompatible with a biblical Christian worldview would be an understatement.
Let’s unravel the nonsense.
The original article discusses an “epic trifecta” of pop culture sensations, championing them as symbols of feminine power and communal meaning. Yet, at its core, the piece is steeped in an ideology that places a premium on feelings, experiences, and worldly trends that are more aligned with Marxist and feminist principles than anything remotely Christian. It twists the biblical understanding of womanhood, community, and worship to fit into a narrative that’s politically charged and panders to a feminized culture. In fact, the author of this piece, Beth Felker Jones, throws her own 18-year-old son under the bus, claiming that he “doesn’t seem put off by the feminine in these events.”
“He’s not losing sleep over the purported feminization of the culture or the accusation that Barbie is demeaning of men” she wrote. “He’s never even heard of the supposed feminization of the church, nor do I think he’s ever considered the idea that such a thing might be a threat to him.”
“I liked how the Kens were metaphors for women in the real world,” Jones claims her son said.
It’s bad enough that the young men in the church aren’t being properly trained to discern good from evil, and are unable to see the threats of false teachings taking over the church at an alarming rate. But the idea that Barbie, an iconic plastic doll, and pop stars like Swift can be heralded for their “theological themes” is so ludicrous that it’s almost laughable. To inject these figures with existential or spiritual meaning is not only naïve but dangerously ill-conceived. It represents a complete abandonment of biblical principles in favor of worldly values that align with left-leaning vain philosophies.
The thesis of the article espouses a worldview that sees entertainment and consumerism as platforms for empowerment, community, and even spiritual growth—the epitome of what Paul meant in Romans 1, “they became futile in their thinking.” It also falls in line with feminist and Marxist standpoint theories that emphasize individual autonomy and subjective experiences, often at the expense of absolute truths and moral standards.
In the article at Christianity Today, one preposterous line stands out:
“Barbie is full of theological themes, and, while I wouldn’t presume to know her faith, Swift has expressed public frustration with ways American Christianity has been attached to partisan politics.”
Really? A plastic doll with theological themes? Pop stars as the arbiters of American Christianity? If we’ve reached the point where we’re taking spiritual cues from toys and child celebrities, we’ve indeed lost our way.
The Church is called to be set apart, not dragged into pagan cultural trends. We are not of this world, and our beliefs, values, and practices should reflect that. We are called to stand firm in our faith, to be unwavering in our commitment to the truth of the Gospel. The flirtation with worldly philosophies and the appropriation of secular culture as something spiritually meaningful is not just foolish—it’s a betrayal of the very essence of our mission.
Jesus called us out of the world. He commanded us to be a light to the nations, not to be a reflection of the worldly trends around us. If Barbie and pop stars are now the standard-bearers for theological insights, then we are indeed playing a fool’s game. We need more godly men to preach the Word and boldly reject and denounce this seemingly never-ending stream of nonsense that distracts us from the truth. The Church is not a playground for cultural experimentation—it’s the body of Christ, called to holiness and obedience to God’s sovereign will. Anything less is a tragic compromise.
I haven't read about any mob violence. No post-concert looting. No police activity. No gunplay. No shootings. No riots. Nothing but Swift's mostly white fans enjoying themselves.
Amen!
**he’s been playing sold out shows all summer longs at NFL stadiums. 50k-70k people each night, often multiple nights in the same city.**
My wife’s input: if she was actually wearing clothes while singing (like Karen Carpenter), instead of parading in sequined and tassled undergarments/swimsuits, displayed on the big screen, would the male turnout be considerably less?
I said: certainly.
Christianity Today hasn’t been Christian for decades.
Lost, lost, lost.
I guess that is another publication not worth reading.
Taylor Swift's costumes are actually pretty tame if you look at them carefully. A lot of skin-colored tights, leggings, etc worn under dresses and bodysuits that are far less revealing than a typical ballerina would wear.
Every stitch she wears on stage has been meticulously engineered to avoid an embarrassing "wardrobe malfunction" that would be photographed from a thousand different angles and spread around the web forever
This is what happens when you depart from Torah. Eventually you run out of spiritual inheritance. You’re account is empty and the checks bounce. You end up living in a tent, strung out on drugs. On the other hand; you could repent and return to the Covenant, and walk in it.
I'm not sure it could be less without actually dropping to zero. My daughter went to one of the Dallas shows with two friends plus one of the friends' mother and grandmother. They said the vast majority of the crowd was female.
People like this that make me not want to call myself a Christian any more, they want to call evil good, I prefer Christ follower.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.