Your discerning meter is off, as I am not Jewish.
I think that was his point.
Most Jewish people don’t consider “messianic Jews” anymore “Jewish”’than, say the black radicals Hebrew Israelites.
(The exception being actual Jewish people who convert, which they consider simply heretics.)
All that to say, I don’t care what non-Jewish people do, provided they are honest and open about it. The Messianics I’ve met in real life tend to be a little weird, but are generally wonderful and earnest people who accept and study the Tanukah. Quite a number have gone all the way and become truly Jewish, rejecting what Jewish people would consider heresy.
This is a Jewish/Noahide caucus thread. Please observe the rules.