[daniel1212]

MHGinTN: if you make the Mother of Jesus into the wife of God then you have the Holy Spirit speciously fathering Jesus[,] and Jesus (God With Us, woman) as Mary’s husband.

Yikes. I didn't say Mary was Jesus' wife. Please calm down. But thank you for giving us example #5254625 of ... (drum roll)... The Claude Paradigm “You Catholics are wrong because you believe X.” “We don’t believe X.” “Wrong again. Yes you do.”

Once again you misconstrue what MHGinTN was responding to, which was not what you actually stated but what he argued was the logical consequence of making Mary the mother of God and the wife of God.

Which i am sure you could respond to rather than misconstruing your opposition.

[Mrs. Don-o]

The Church does not teach that Mary is the Mother of God the Father or God the Holy Spirit.

Mary conceived in her womb and gave birth to Jesus Christ Our Lord. He is God. This does not mean she gave birth to the Trinity.

I think we both realize that. Whether this other party in TN realizes that, I do not know.