“Tax-chick asked me no question;”
Your failure then was to someone else.
“there was, therefore, no answer to make.”
This is a question: “What will the Bibles place be in Heaven?” What you posted was an answer to it. You’re now saying you didn’t do it. You even quoted what question you were answering: http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-religion/3476011/posts#18
“Your criticism fails for relevance.”
My criticism is spot on and your own post shows it.
Did you happen to notice that Tax-chick did not ask that question?
Oops. Didn't read it closely enough, did you.
Vlad's argument fails, catastrophically.
Checkmate.
Have an nice life.