Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Dating Apps and the Death of Romance
Catholic News Agency ^ | Dec 23, 2015 | Mary Rezac

Posted on 01/01/2016 3:20:35 AM PST by BlessedBeGod

Denver, Colo., Dec 23, 2015 / 07:14 am (CNA).- This September's issue of Vanity Fair contains a pretty disheartening prediction for single people: the "dating apocalypse," brought on by wildly popular dating apps like "Tinder," is upon us.

Young singles are too busy swiping left and right on their phones making shallow, transient connections, rather than finding real love with real people. Romance is dead, proposes author Nancy Jo Sales.

What sets Tinder apart from most other dating app or online dating experiences is speed and brevity. Based on a photo, first name, and age alone, users decide whether to swipe left (to pass) or right (to like). With GPS tracking, the app also tells users exactly how far away potential matches may be, making life even easier for those just looking for a quick hook-up.

Shallowest dating app ever?

The biggest criticism of Tinder? It's a seriously shallow app that turns people into quickly-judged commodities on a screen.

In a 2013 article by The Guardian, "Tinder: the shallowest dating app ever?" author Pete Cashmore explains the ick-factor, yet addictiveness, of Tinder when compared to another dating app called Twine.

"Of the two apps, though, Tinder sounded worse, just because it seemed so contemptuously superficial. There are hundreds upon thousands of women, about whom you know almost nothing, and you snap-appraise them with a single swipe. It's a finger-flicking hymn to the instant gratification of the smartphone age. It's addictive."

Matt Fradd is a Catholic speaker and author and founder of The Porn Effect, a website with a mission to "expose the reality behind the fantasy of pornography and to equip individuals to find freedom from it." In his ministry, he's heard a lot of stories from young people about their struggle to overcome objectifying people through porn.

Fradd had some harsh words for Tinder.

"Tinder exists for those who would rather not purchase a prostitute," he told CNA.

"I would imagine most people who use that app aren't there because they're looking for a chaste relationship," he added.

And indeed, quite a bit of colloquial evidence backs him up. Alex in the Vanity Fair article said dating apps have turned romance into a competition of "Who's slept with the best, hottest girls?"

"You could talk to two or three girls at a bar and pick the best one, or you can swipe a couple hundred people a day--the sample size is so much larger," he said. "It's setting up two or three Tinder dates a week and, chances are, sleeping with all of them, so you could rack up 100 girls you've slept with in a year."

But Tinder doesn't always have to be that way, users argue. It is possible to find people on the app who want to go on some good old-fashioned dates.

Tinder users speak

Ross is a twenty-something Nebraska-to-New York City transplant and a cradle Catholic who's used his fair share of both dating apps and sites. When signing up for Tinder, Ross said, probably the most important factor in whether someone will find potential dates or hook-ups is location, location, location.

"Your region matters so much," he told CNA in an e-mail interview. "In Nebraska, women date on Tinder. They really do....In New York, (most) want a distraction, attention, and/or a hook up. Not emotion or connections."

Holly, a twenty-something devout Catholic living in Kansas City, said she has had success finding a date - and a pretty decent one at that - on the app.

"I went on a great Tinder date. Granted it was the only Tinder date, but we even went out a few times before things ended. At the time Tinder sort of freaked me out, but I decided to jump in head first and it was an enjoyable experience over all," she said.

Many young people who've used Tinder also argue that the "shallow" critique is a bit overblown, considering that dating always takes into account whether or not a potential mate is physically attractive.

"How is me swiping right on a guy that I find attractive, and swiping left (on those) that I'm not that into any different than someone approaching a guy that I find attractive in a bar? We make snap judgements all the time. Why is it suddenly so much worse if I'm doing it online?" asked Michelle, a twenty-something practicing Catholic who lives in Chicago.

While she's definitely experienced the creepier side of Tinder - with guys sending her "rankings" on a scale of 1 to 10 and other, um, less-than-endearing messages, she said she found the app could be used as a way to maybe meet some new people in person and to get recommendations of things to do in the city.

"I think to immediately classify Tinder or any other dating app as a 'hook-up' app or as a very bad thing goes against the idea that things are morally neutral," Michelle said. "Just like alcohol is not inherently bad but can be used for evil, I don't think Tinder is inherently evil as well. I definitely think you can use Tinder if you're using it to meet people - not to hook up with people."

The morality of Tinder

It's admittedly a bit difficult to find someone who can speak with moral authority specifically to dating apps in the Catholic world. Because of the very recent explosion of smartphones, followed by the subsequent explosion of dating apps, or because of vows of celibacy, many clergy and moral experts have actually never used dating apps themselves.

Fr. Gregory Plow, T.O.R., falls into that category. Even though he's a young priest and friar who's never used Tinder, Fr. Plow works with hundreds of young people every day as the director of Households at Franciscan University of Steubenville, Ohio (kind of like Greek houses, but faith-based).

Fr. Plow said when Catholics determine the morality of any act or tool, like Tinder, three things must be considered.

"Whenever discerning the morality of an act not explicitly defined by Church teaching, we must examine the object, the intention, and the circumstances," he said, referencing paragraph 1757 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church.

"Regarding the 'object,' apps - in general, as an invention - are not bad in and of themselves. Like most other technologies, they are morally neutral in and of themselves," he said. "Apps do, however, possess a certainly quality of being transitory that can factor in to the other two components (intention and circumstances) that factor in to judging the morality of an act."

The transitory, cursory nature of swiping based on one picture in Tinder can be morally dangerous if that same mentality transfers to relationships with people, he said. Instead of pausing and taking the time to form real relationships, some people may decide to move on to the next best thing because they have so many options.

"Therefore, in as much dating apps are impersonal and transitory, or are used with the intention for receiving gratification and pleasure, they are immoral," he said. "If, however, online dating apps or services assisting people in leading them to find another person to share the love of God with in the uniqueness of a dating relationship or marriage, it can be (morally) good."

Mary Beth Bonacci, a Catholic speaker and author on John Paul II's Theology of the Body, said what's concerning about Tinder when compared to online dating sites such as CatholicMatch is the rapidity with which people can be turned into objects.

"The entire realm of dating is full of opportunities to turn a human person into a commodity. We get so wrapped up in thinking about what we want for ourselves that we forget we are dealing with another human person - an image and likeness of God. It's always been a temptation," she said.

"But the rapid-fire nature of Tinder's 'scan and swipe' makes it easy to turn many, many human persons into commodities in a short period of time. That is what is scariest to me."

Bonacci said while it's possible to find someone who's interested in a virtuous dating relationship through apps like Tinder, the chances of that happening are probably pretty low when compared with online dating sites that have more extensive profiles.

Meeting someone in person as soon as possible is also key, she said, in determining whether or not a match made online or in an app has a chance of turning into a dating relationship. But apps like Tinder aren't exactly helping breathe new life into romance, she said.

"Everything is instant. The nearly-anonymous sex is of course the antithesis of anything romantic or respectful. In the old days of the 'meat market' singles' bar, a person had to get dressed up, leave the house, buy a few drinks and at least pretend to have some real interest in the other person."

The Church has a duty, she said, to offer young people better alternatives in the dating world than the instant gratification that they find in the current culture.

"The Vanity Fair article reminded me once again that we have to offer teens and young adults an alternative to the degrading, hook up world that surrounds them. We can't scare them out of it. They need to be inspired, to fall in love with the real beauty of the Christian vision of human sexual morality," she said.

"They need to see their own dignity, their own importance, and how respecting their bodies and the beautiful language of human sexuality is the only way to finding real love. We have to. We can't allow another generation of kids to fall into this cesspool."


TOPICS: Catholic; Current Events; Moral Issues; Religion & Culture
KEYWORDS:

1 posted on 01/01/2016 3:20:35 AM PST by BlessedBeGod
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod

Yearning for the “good old days” when we went to the bars, got trashed, and sought out a mate.


2 posted on 01/01/2016 4:47:01 AM PST by sakic
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod

{Instead of pausing and taking the time to form real relationships, some people may decide to move on to the next best thing because they have so many options. (At least) in the old days of the ‘meat market’ singles’ bar, a person had to get dressed up, leave the house, buy a few drinks and at least pretend to have some real interest in the other person.”}………

And now, when and if they do agree to meet they’re caught with the awkwardness of actually having to SPEAK to one another in full, coherent sentences, instead of texting each other to death.


3 posted on 01/01/2016 4:47:08 AM PST by fivecatsandadog ( "Radical" Muslims will kill you. "Moderates" will sit in silence and watch the radicals kill you.)
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod

It isn’t all Tinder. Three of my best friends, all serious Catholics, all looking for serious Catholic wives. They were all in their early thirties to early forties with no previous marriages, employed, but introverted. All three found their wives on CatholicMatch or CatholicSingles. I was best man at two of the three weddings. It is now 10-17 years later, all are married, with children and doing fine as far as I know.


4 posted on 01/01/2016 4:58:46 AM PST by Dr. Sivana (There is no salvation in politics)
[ Post Reply]

To: sakic

Back in the good ol’ days, flirting and guys sometimes being jerks and getting to know people we knew nothing about were FUN. Where’s the romance without all that?


5 posted on 01/01/2016 5:00:49 AM PST by grania
[ Post Reply]

To: Dr. Sivana

I definitely think technology created a more efficient means of screening potential mates, though a friend that used a Catholic dating site was not happy to meet a pro-abortion “Catholic” through one - the screen failed.

I agree with the points about “superficial”, but the fact is that if someone is unattractive to a “seeker” why waste time setting up a meeting? Certainly does put a lot of stock in pictures, though. I’ve been married for years, and was done with dating before cell phone themselves were common; I couldn’t imagine dating today (though I think technology would help).


6 posted on 01/01/2016 5:36:51 AM PST by kearnyirish2 (Affirmative action is economic warfare against white males (and therefore white families).)
[ Post Reply]

To: Dr. Sivana

Dating websites and dating apps are two different things. You referenced a website, while the article discusses an app. Dating apps are incorrectly named; they should be called hookup apps. People use them simply to find someone with which to have sex. There is no expectation of a relationship.


7 posted on 01/01/2016 5:46:13 AM PST by goodwithagun (My gun has killed fewer people than Ted Kennedy's car.)
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod
Another year-end filler article? Technology is neutral. How people choose to use it is what matters. Dating and hookups are something people have done since before recorded history. Technology may improve efficiency, but it doesn't change the fundamentals.

You can now find contact apps for everything from casual hookups to arranged marriage. The technology may change but the dance remains the same.

8 posted on 01/01/2016 6:04:29 AM PST by AustinBill (consequence is what makes our choices real)
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod
One picture? Even the local shelter in my area offers up to 3 pictures of dogs and cats available for adoption, along with important stats like "Housebroken - Yes, No, Unknown". Of course, adopting a dog is a bigger commitment than one date with a member of the opposite sex.

And even if you don't have to get dressed up and go someplace, you can still have beer goggle eyes and swipe the wrong way...

9 posted on 01/01/2016 6:25:47 AM PST by Bernard (The Road To Hell Is Not Paved With Good Results)
[ Post Reply]

To: grania

If kids today are doing this, they are having fun. People always seek out fun. Always been that way.

Not sure what’s romantic about Jenks in bars.

Romance comes after you meet someone, not when you meet them.


10 posted on 01/01/2016 6:36:54 AM PST by sakic
[ Post Reply]

To: BlessedBeGod

All these dating apps are just high tech vanity validation for the attractive photogenic types. The average looking need not apply.


11 posted on 01/01/2016 6:43:59 AM PST by central_va (I won't be reconstructed and I do not give a damn.)
[ Post Reply]

To: sakic
Not sure what's romantic about jerks in bars...

Sometimes it was worth looking past all that, and finding someone special hidden behind that mask. (I reminisce)

12 posted on 01/01/2016 7:34:24 AM PST by grania
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson