“But they aren’t,”
They are.
“and you are simply wrong.”
Not even close.
“We do not have the same doctrine, and targeting only sola scriptura and sola fide means you have somehow left out 3 of the solas.”
It doesn’t matter - since only those two are peculiar to Protestants.
“And since Catholics subscribe to 3, 4, and 5 (and probably 2), that means Catholics are Protestants, too.”
Nope. And even you now are saying that I was right by showing that only sola fide and sola scriptura are peculiarly Protestant.
So, what about those Methodists and their quadrilateral: scripture, tradition, reason, experience?
I understand you to be saying that Roman Catholics do not believe that a saved Catholic has to be a believer. If you are not saying that, then you affirm ‘sola fide’.