While the voting was held in secret, everything else was public.
My point was that whole thing wasn’t some secret cabal where novel doctrine was created and then rubber stamped by the Pope.
No, rather novel doctrine was proposed (see the interim report) and then resoundingly shot down by a few real Catholic bishops; thus; a speechless Francis could not rubber stamp that which he had wanted to stamp.
That is where, in my opinion, the Holy Ghost may have come into play.
P.S. One of those few, real Catholic bishops has been rudely removed from three of his posts and exiled to an "honorary" position. Will you blame that action on Kasper; or will you finally admit to who's pulling Kasper puppet strings? Who has brought Kasper back into the limelight and set him upon a pedestal?
No, not only was the the voting held in secret, so were the discussions/debates held in secret.
Only post-session interviews were allowed.
If I'm wrong, please publish or tell us the source where we can read the full discussion that occurred during Francis' secret Sin-Nod. Maybe then, we can make more semblance of who voted for what sins.