I like your clear, no-nonsense approach. Too bad it took all the waffling, hand-wringing and kumbaya "we still love ya bro...oops, we mean that in a good way" crap. But, ultimately they fired him. I wonder what they mean by, "...he still has value." Value to his lover? Value as a bad example?
Of these three, I can comment on two of them. The first: He has 'value' in the sense that Christ died for him and desires him to repent, turn from his sin and live. Doesn't look like he was interested in that path so they rightly fired him. In this regard, the third reason becomes valid.
I question the clown in his reasoning that while he had a secret 'that one engaged in bad behavior wouldn't have prospered in his ministry'. Does not manifest evil prosper in this world? The sign of a hardened heart.
RE: “...he still has value.” Value to his lover? Value as a bad example?
How about value as a human being made in God’s image whose values can be redeemed?