“Muslims and Christians both profess to worship the God of Abraham. John Paul II was not wrong to make that point nor to take Muslims at their word even of their understanding of God is limited by their unbelief in the Trinity.”
He said they worship the same God. He did not say they profess to worship the same God, even though they really don’t. Your religion is wrong to claim that Muslims worship the God of the Bible. In reality, they worship a demonic moon-god who is a badly perverted version of the one found in the Bible. He is an idol that does not exist.
” But again, since you lost on Brewer, I guess next we can expect the kitchen sink.”
Sounds like you’re losing the debate, since you’re already claiming victory. But more important than the debate though is the truth.
“He said they worship the same God. He did not say they profess to worship the same God, even though they really don’t.”
Since his statement was not part of the ordinary magisterium and it wasn’t an ex cathedra pronouncement I really don’t care what he said. It changes exactly nothing of the faith.
“Your religion is wrong to claim that Muslims worship the God of the Bible.”
Your opinion is duly noted, but you’re opinion is based on a false premise. The CCC, which is the statement that matters since it is that which is a sure norm, says “profess”. Case closed.
“In reality, they worship a demonic moon-god who is a badly perverted version of the one found in the Bible. He is an idol that does not exist.”
And none of that changes the fact that you’re wrong about Brewer.