[piusv]

I can’t speak for the poster you quoted but I am going to guess that what he/she meant was that the question of the OP can only be answered by God. Having said that, I think I see what you are implying...that, although God makes the final call through his mercy, we have a responsibility to fraternally correct those who are heading down the wrong path.

[Elsie]

...we have a responsibility to fraternally correct those who are heading down the wrong path.

And just WHO is to JUDGE someone is on the WRONG path??