Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article

To: annalex
"I get the icon just by looking at it."

You've been trained in Christian iconography...so, just like a native English reader, you would glean all sorts of information from a road sign written in English, but the identical sign written in Hangul...not so much.

I'm sure I visualize that icon in much the same way you do. It clearly speaks of Christ born of the Virgin, the presence of the Divine as well as the simple human tenderness inherent in the mother and child relationship. To one devoid of that visual vocabulary, it's a giant woman, holding a small balding man with plates behind their heads.

While you and I 'get' and appreciate the faith based context and content, the human tenderness and pathos is equally present in a secular rendering of Picasso's Mother and Child:

The 'nordics', using the term loosely for northern Europeans, had rich visual traditions, predating Christianity, albeit in many cases, more abstract than representative. Take for example this Viking carving...

Even into the Christian era, northern art while cruder, was often wonderfully expressive with extreme pathos:

Curiously, with the reformation, press, and northern Renaissance, even northern Catholic artists continued with the more emotional, mystical subject matter. Grunewald painted this roughly contemporaneous to Luther's 95 Theses:

Subsequently, northern art became increasingly secularized, mundane and worldly in its subject matter. My contention therefore is it's not particularly anything inherent in the climate, genetics, language, etc., as in the pre-Christian and pre-reformation eras, northern artists were fully willing and capable of highly expressive, spiritual subject matter. Something shifted in their choice of subject matter and the manner in which they chose to portray it, and that something was roughly contemporaneous to the advent of protestantism and widespread dissemination of the printed word.

I would contend that as literacy spread, predominantly in the north, holy imagery became less and less an integral and essential element of religious instruction in some areas with a resulting de-emphasis on them. In other areas, where literacy grew less rapidly, the tradition remained essential, and became increasingly ingrained as a fundamental aspect of religious instruction, understanding, and ritual.

18 posted on 11/10/2012 4:53:51 PM PST by Joe 6-pack (Que me amat, amet et canem meum)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 17 | View Replies ]


To: Joe 6-pack
Indeed, it is more mysterious than southern vivaciousness versus northern morosity. The icon, after all, is Russian, the gloomiest nation on earth. This is why I put "hot" and "cold" in quotes.

Further, it is not to deny the North artistic genius. It is, if anything, the Italians who created modern sensual but despiritualized art.

How about this:

At around AD 1500, the Christian Civilization took a turn from the synthetic to the analytic. Things became compartmentalized into: this is art, that is spiritual, and that is decorative. Also, this is church, that is state. This is business, that is charity. Art goes to museums, spiritual goes to churches, decoration is used but ignored. Art in church is very nice but it really belongs to a museum. A cross in a museum is a historical artifact, with a label. The Nelson-Atkins museum in KC has a full-wall altar and a finger of St. John the Baptist; I am the only one there praying. The ability to talk to an icon was lost, and with it the art of prayer was lost.

The Smolensk icon is one of the less popular ones, with Christ shown ageless. I studied it, so I know. But one who has not studied looking at it still sees a mystery, like you said, giant woman with a small balding man. That's it: the sign that is the the thing signed. Look in awe.

19 posted on 11/10/2012 6:40:12 PM PST by annalex (fear them not)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Religion
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson