Whatever happened to *once a Catholic, always a Catholic* and that baptism into the Catholic church leaves an indelible mark on the soul?
On what or whose authority do you disown those whom the Catholic church has not ex-communicated and who the Catholic church still counts as members to make that 1.2 billion strong?
As I said only CINOs — not practicing Catholics.
They will always be a baptized Catholics and have to answer for the fruit they bear in their lives.