Exactly -- you either believe He was who He said He was, or he was a madman and a liar. Nothing in between.
The hypostatic Union comes into play here. His nature was Divine and Human.
We could bring in Mary and the thread will go wild!!
The Holy Spirit gave Mary His Divine side with her Fiat (Latin -she said yes- not raped) and Mary gave Him the Human side with her humanity.
Perfect - just right for Justice-