[Cronos]

RM -- you said that "Do not spread arguments from one thread to another. Engage the argument on the original thread unless the issues are raised anew on the current thread. "

These links do just that and by this rule this post should not be allowed. Note that these are both spreading arguments from one thread to another and also in in cases (like "how to train ...") are not relevant to the issue of the thread at all.

[Religion Moderator]

No dice. Alex Murphy's is a list of links to ARTICLES not reply posts. Salvation also posts lists of links to articles.

The guideline applies to disputes between individual Freepers, past flame wars - bringing them forward to a new thread is flame baiting, trouble making.

[Hegewisch Dupa]

Maybe it's because Murph's arguments are so weak they don't count? Like the internet equivelent of a height requirement in front of a roller coaster: "your argument must make at least this much sense for any one to care about it..."