[Onelifetogive]

the guy who gave up because he didn't want to wrestle a girl gets to go home.

Not so much:

Although the home-schooled sophomore was allowed to compete in the consolations round, due to default and not forfeit, it is possible for him and Herkelman to be matched up again if they both make it to the finals.

[GunRunner]

Not so much:

He got beat in the consolations round and is going home. If he'd have wrestled her and won he'd still have a chance in the tournament.

[xone]

it is possible for him and Herkelman to be matched up again if they both make it to the finals.

That would be consolation finals, for third, and she is out of the tourney unless HS in Iowa go to 8th place.