[marshmallow]

If you have some Catholic drum to bang, why not do it on a Catholic website?

IOW, Catholicism not welcome on FR? Is that the take-home message?

It does not “further conservatism in America” to post a divisive thread which you consider closed to everyone who disagrees.

Which I consider closed.......??

I'm not responsible for establishing the rules about "Caucus" threads and who may participate in them.

It's not clear to me what the problem is here.

Do you have a problem with the whole concept of "Caucus" threads per se, or is it only Catholic caucus threads with which you have an issue?

[A.A. Cunningham]

Behind every double standard lies an unconfessed single standard.

[Cronos]

“Is that the take-home message?” —> that does seem to be the take-home message these days.