[freedumb2003]

Hey, if you find happiness by trashing the Mother of Our Lord and Savior, I won’t stand in the way.

Thousands of years of theological study and discussion give way to your prejudice.

You win the thread, I suppose.

[metmom]

Where have I trashed her?

If you’re going to accuse me of something, back it up.

[Puddleglum]

I answered this topic with the correct answer, “Yes,” 48,214 posts ago. But words and arguments aren't going to settle it because of human nature being what it is and the fact that the Bible does not address this with a Boolean checkbox (”Sinful? Sinless? Pacific Islander? Other [Please Explain]”.

If I'm wrong, and Mary was sinful, I'll give everyone on this thread who was correct a coupon for a slightly bigger mansion and/or crown in heaven than they deserve. If I'm right, you must do whatever penance Purgatory requires of people who go to churches that preach sermons about Ruth or Sarah or Hagar or that lady Obadiah mentions twice or anyone but Mary on Mother's Day.