Skip to comments.
Pope: condoms can be justified in some cases [such as for male prostitutes]
Kansas City Star ^
| 11-20-10
| NICOLE WINFIELD and FRANCES D'EMILIO
Posted on 11/20/2010 11:38:36 AM PST by mlizzy
Pope Benedict XVI says in a new book that condoms can be justified for male prostitutes seeking to stop the spread of HIV, a stunning comment for a church criticized for its opposition to condoms and for a pontiff who has blamed them for making the AIDS crisis worse.
The pope made the comments in a book-length interview with a German journalist, "Light of the World: The Pope, the Church and the Signs of the Times," which is being released Tuesday. The Vatican newspaper ran excerpts on Saturday.
Church teaching has long opposed condoms because they are a form of artificial contraception, although it has never released an explicit policy about condoms and HIV. The Vatican has been harshly criticized for its opposition.
Benedict said that condoms are not a moral solution. But he said in some cases, such as for male prostitutes, they could be justified "in the intention of reducing the risk of infection."
Benedict called it "a first step in a movement toward a different way, a more human way of living sexuality."
He used as an example male prostitutes, for whom contraception is not an issue, as opposed to married couples where one spouse is infected. The Vatican has come under pressure from even some church officials in Africa to condone condom use for monogamous married couples to protect the uninfected spouse from getting infected.
Continue reading here.
(Excerpt) Read more at kansascity.com ...
TOPICS: Catholic
KEYWORDS: aids; catholic; condoms
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-48 next last
This is a much better article.
1
posted on
11/20/2010 11:38:41 AM PST
by
mlizzy
Comment #2 Removed by Moderator
To: mlizzy
This is about condom use for [possibly] male prostitutes, who can’t procreate anyway.
3
posted on
11/20/2010 11:40:27 AM PST
by
mlizzy
(Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee ...)
To: Tax-chick
Yep, you're right! On another thread, they're saying all sorts of untruths in this regard. That the Pope said unmarried people could use condoms, that couples could use condoms, etc. and so on ...
People are so quick to rip Catholicism ...
4
posted on
11/20/2010 11:45:02 AM PST
by
mlizzy
(Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee ...)
To: mlizzy
And they call it ‘social justice’....
To: mlizzy
Oh, I know. I don’t participate in threads started by some posters, at all.
It’s not as if the Church hasn’t made it clear that all sodomitic activity is a sin. Adding condoms to that activity is morally irrelevant. Wear condoms for self-abuse, too; the Church doesn’t care.
6
posted on
11/20/2010 11:47:47 AM PST
by
Tax-chick
(Global Warming: the first faith preached exclusively by hypocrites.)
To: mlizzy
I must have been missing out on something here.
Was there some moral “justification” for condoms? Personally, I hate the things, but if people want to use them, to each his own. I don’t see how it’s any business of the Pope when it comes to what people do in their bedrooms. He must think alot of himself to make such proclamations.
7
posted on
11/20/2010 11:50:49 AM PST
by
KoRn
(Department of Homeland Security, Certified - "Right Wing Extremist")
To: KoRn
He must think alot of himself to make such proclamations.He is the vicar of Christ He proclaims and it comes straight from the Throne Of God
Personally to me he's just a guy with a funny hat
8
posted on
11/20/2010 12:00:38 PM PST
by
Popman
(Obama. First Marxist to turn a five year Marxist plan into a 4 year administration.)
To: Popman
Really, you should know what you’re talking about before moving your fingers across the keyboard.
9
posted on
11/20/2010 12:08:10 PM PST
by
Pyro7480
("If you know how not to pray, take Joseph as your master, and you will not go astray." - St. Teresa)
To: KoRn
He must think alot of himself to make such proclamations.
Yeah, just who does he think he is, the Pope? *smiles*
10
posted on
11/20/2010 12:18:18 PM PST
by
mlizzy
(Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee ...)
To: Pyro7480
Are you telling me the Pope is not the Vicar of Christ or his hat isn’t funny looking ?
11
posted on
11/20/2010 12:20:43 PM PST
by
Popman
(Obama. First Marxist to turn a five year Marxist plan into a 4 year administration.)
To: Popman
No, I'm referring to this:
He proclaims and it comes straight from the Throne Of God.
That is a fundamental misunderstanding of papal infallibility.
12
posted on
11/20/2010 12:22:09 PM PST
by
Pyro7480
("If you know how not to pray, take Joseph as your master, and you will not go astray." - St. Teresa)
To: mlizzy
Comment from a
thread on this article from a Catholic forum:
Actually, that's their interpretation of what His Holiness said. Bits from the book that I found on the web indicate that what the interviewer did was ask the Pope if condoms would help in not transmitting HIV, and the Pope admitted they did stop the disease transmission, but then gave that quote about condoms not being a real solution. To the media, this is saying that condoms are OK. You have to remember that it's in their interests to get people to think the Church contradicts itself. That way, it's easier for them to make the case that "Well, the Church has contradicted her teachings before, so women priests should be OK now".
13
posted on
11/20/2010 12:30:04 PM PST
by
Brian Kopp DPM
(Liberalism is infecund.)
To: mlizzy
Thanks for this. I found a yahoo story, but I hate to excerpt stories. When I saw the male prostitues part of the quote, I realized that the other thread was not an honest assessment.
14
posted on
11/20/2010 12:34:49 PM PST
by
Salvation
("With God all things are possible." Matthew 19:26)
To: mlizzy
such as for male prostitutes, they could be justified "in the intention of reducing the risk of infection." I don't even accept that, not by a long shot.
If one intends fidelity to Catholic moral principles, be skeptical of everything that comes out of the Vatican post~1960. Especially papal opinions that imply wrongs are justified sometimes "just because". Do nothing to facilitate on-going evil.
15
posted on
11/20/2010 12:35:42 PM PST
by
steve86
To: mlizzy
Ok, lots of issues with this.
1. Condoms are more likely to rip/tear during sodomous acts.
2. Condoms are not effective in preventing AIDS: I will try to find a source, but I once read the while they are 99% effective at preventing pregnancy if used properly but only around 85% effective in preventing the spread of HIV. I thought the reason was because the virus is much smaller than a sperm cell, and therefore easier to get through the pores of the condom. Feel free to contradict or help find supporting sources!
3. The Pope needs to speak about the sin of sodomy, as well as the dangers of Christians accepting the gay lifestyle. It would be great if he could bring attention to all the negative side effects, mentally and physically.
16
posted on
11/20/2010 12:42:49 PM PST
by
goodwithagun
(My gun has killed fewer people than Ted Kennedy's car.)
To: Salvation
You're welcome. I showed my husband the other thread, and he said, "WHAT!?" And then he said, "See if you can find out what the Pope really said" ...
17
posted on
11/20/2010 12:44:28 PM PST
by
mlizzy
(Hail Mary, full of grace, the Lord is with thee ...)
To: Pyro7480
So when the Pope speaks “ ex cathedra” which is part of Vatican I and papal infallabily it is inspired by what:
God though the Holy Spirit
Satan
spaghetti monster in the sky
BTW, I think highy of the Pope - I simply don't believe who the RC church claims who he is and I might add I am very well versed in RC doctrine so you may want to defend your faith to the death but I don't plan on wasting my time watching you die
18
posted on
11/20/2010 12:48:58 PM PST
by
Popman
(Obama. First Marxist to turn a five year Marxist plan into a 4 year administration.)
To: steve86
OK, the Church condemns sex outside of marriage (which would include sex with prostitutes), and condemns homosexual actions. There's also the fifth commandment--"Thou shalt not kill."
If a person is determined to go ahead and be a male prostitute, but can either spread a deadly disease or not spread a deadly disease, I don't see what's wrong with saying "don't also kill the person you are having wrongful sexual relations with."
David committed adultery with Bathsheba, which led to some embarrassing consequences. He could have avoided those consequences by killing her right after they had sex. I don't think anyone would argue that the more moral thing for David to have done, after seducing Bathsheba, was to have killed her.
To: mlizzy
Here's the yahoo thread and the exceprt:
Pope: condoms can be justified in some cases
By NICOLE WINFIELD and FRANCES D'EMILIO, Associated Press Nicole Winfield And Frances D'emilio, Associated Press
1 hr 42 mins ago
VATICAN CITY Pope Benedict XVI says in a new book that condoms can be justified for male prostitutes seeking to stop the spread of HIV, a stunning comment for a church criticized for its opposition to condoms and for a pontiff who has blamed them for making the AIDS crisis worse.
The pope made the comments in a book-length interview with a German journalist, "Light of the World: The Pope, the Church and the Signs of the Times," which is being released Tuesday. The Vatican newspaper ran excerpts on Saturday.
Church teaching has long opposed condoms because they are a form of artificial contraception, although it has never released an explicit policy about condoms and HIV. The Vatican has been harshly criticized for its opposition.
20
posted on
11/20/2010 12:51:44 PM PST
by
Salvation
("With God all things are possible." Matthew 19:26)
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-48 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson