So does that tell us anything about “Catholics” in the Caribbean, or “Protestants” in the Caribbean, in ANY general sense?
NO, it does not, any more than it tells us anything, in a general sense about “Catholics” or “Protestants” anywhere;
except that no matter what religious faith we are talking about, some people practice the social and obligatory acts of a religious faith but do not in fact live-out the religious tenants of that faith.
How does that place the LDS members differently, in that regard?
It doesn’t. Therefore what was the meaning of your original point? Nothing, it was pointless.
Apostle Urges Mormons to Speak Up, Avoid Defensiveness
Then your complaint needs to go to the AUTHOR; that his ARTICLE was pointless. HE is the one making the generalized statements.