Posted on 05/22/2009 2:14:15 PM PDT by franksolich
I went over to TxRadioGuy's hometown forum, to see an argument ongoing there, about how enemy combatants should be treated.
And as usual, there's a primitive mucking up a passage ostensibly from the Bible, but which actually goes back much further than that (Christ was saying it as then-ancient history).
This "eye for an eye" bit.
I have no idea why that's considered a bad thing.
Of course, it's considered a bad thing because it's always misinterpreted.
(Excerpt) Read more at conservativecave.com ...
Sort of a ping for the list.
Does he mean that we should put them in a building and slam a jetliner into it so they can burn to death?
We have more economical methods of dispatching them......
Never in Jewish history has it been interpreted any differently. Jewish courts have never plucked out eyes or teeth, etc.
Christ was quoting Moses, or anyway his Law, not Hammurabi. Exodus 20 or so, if I remember corrrectly. Hammurabi came well before the Mosaic Law, so in all likelihood the use of the term in the Law was restating a commonplace of Middle Eastern legal systems.
I’ve also never quite understood why the lex talionis is considered so savage. Exactly what is unjust about forcing the perp to suffer the same injury he intentionally inflicted on another person? Since the perp is a guilty person and the victim was innocent, strict justice might even require greater injury being done to “even things up.”
The Law, BTW, applied this principle only to violent crimes. There was none of the hand-chopping for property crimes so popular in sharia.
Well, essentially that’s what it means.
Not strictly an eye for an eye, but for the thief to recompense his one-eyed victim for the harm done him.
Very interesting. I didn’t know this.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.