[Pyro7480]

How is salus’s comment bad?

[marshmallow]

How is salus’s comment bad?

The Pope is not "orthodox" nor "solid" enough.

You agree with that?

[mick]

I had a conversation with my 90yr old father yesterday. He is reading a book about slavery in America where there is evidently some historical dispute as to the actual number of Africans that were brought across the ocean to become slaves. And we discussed how the number, while interesting from an historical point of view, is irrelevant to the evil of slavery. But we still wanted to know the facts.

It got me to thinking.....why is it antisemitic to even question the number of Jews killed by the Nazis?...isn't that a historical question that is interesting in it's own right?

But it seems to ask that question today,to want to know the facts, which has nothing to do with diminishing the evil of the Holocaust, is somehow a bad thing, subject to censure. Now why is that?

[NYer]

And finally, this from salus: "Pray the Pope becomes more solid and orthodox especially in appointing Bishops.">

How is this comment bad? More orthodox than who? If anyone should be looking at bishops that have been appointed, it is these folks. The SSPX illicitly appointed Williamson, the very source of anti-Semitism, not the Holy Father. I hope, Pyro, that you are not in agreement with their anti-semite teachings.