You wrote:
“So then which bones are they now claiming to be Peter’s: the skull bones at St John Lateran or those skeletal bones under St Peter’s Basilica???”
Who is “they”? Is there any official Catholic teaching about any of these bones? No, none. So who is “they”?
“They can’t have it both ways especially in this age of DNA analysis.”
Again, who is “they”?
“Well, I guess you can though if you’re the Vatican magisterium.”
There’s no such thing as the Vatican magisterium. It’s just the magisterium. If you’re going to attack something wouldn’t help if you knew what you were talking about?
Several posts back you were trying to pawn off on us Walsh's book about the bones --- Now you are backpedalling as fast as a Vatican retreat. LOLOL!!!!!