Let me get this straight: God writes the script and says "Man must rebel against me. The only reason he shall rebel again me is that I say it must happen.
Oh, the rebellion was real, but is was God's will, according to you, that man commit the first sin. And, although you try clumsily to introduce 'free will' so that man can be blamed for his disobedience, at the same time you state that God's will cannot be opposed. So, in truth, man did not have a choice, but was predestined to rebel.
Then, if I am reading your theology correctly, man was trapped from the get-go to fall into the pit of sin created by God.
Man did nothing God didn't allow him to do
No, FK, I believe you are tripping over your own theology. In the first paragraph you said it had to be. You didn't say, God allowed it, so it was a tossup. In your book, there is no choice. God didn't leave it up to us to decide.
Which is it: did God predetermine everything, including our choices, or not? If God predetermined our choices, then He is the author of them and we are simply the vessels who must obey.
If you must obey, you have no choice. If you obey God's will, regardless what your choice is, and you must, how is that a sin?
No, all sin is through free will choice
Tripping...
We follow our nature, unless it is changed by God
And I though you said we follow what God says we must do. Which is it, FK?
If not, then sin in general is what makes God angry and offended
Why? From what you are telling me sin is something that had to happen because God says so. If our rebellion and fall is the result of something God said must happen, knew it would happen, made sure it happens, then why is He 'offended?' I hope you realize you didn't answer my question.
You say it like it's a bad thing. :) I take it that you believe in the alternative: God doesn't write a script and doesn't care one way or the other what men do with His creation. Whatever they decide to do, that is fine with Him. Man rebelling against God was an accident, it didn't have to go that way, but fate or fortune or luck determined it instead.
So, in truth, man did not have a choice, but was predestined to rebel.
God could have created Adam and Eve to be immune to sin. He did not. Therefore, that sin would happen was part of God's plan. That is, if God is in control of His creation. If man is in control of God's creation, then I suppose Adam choosing to sin was just a bad roll of the dice.
Then, if I am reading your theology correctly, man was trapped from the get-go to fall into the pit of sin created by God.
No, God did not create sin. However, it was part of God's plan that man would sin, and God always gets what He wants. Man cannot thwart God's plan.
I believe you are tripping over your own theology. In the first paragraph you said it had to be. You didn't say, God allowed it, so it was a tossup. ..... Which is it: did God predetermine everything, including our choices, or not? If God predetermined our choices, then He is the author of them and we are simply the vessels who must obey.
God does predetermine everything, which means God allowing something does not make it a tossup. It is a difference of God acting versus choosing not to act. That is the difference in authorship. When we do good, God acts and gets the credit. When we sin, God does nothing, and we are to blame. So, when I sin I am not "obeying" God. He does not "move" me to sin.
If you must obey, you have no choice. If you obey God's will, regardless what your choice is, and you must, how is that a sin?
Sin is acting against God. It is our nature to do so before salvation. After salvation we still choose to so act from time to time. You can't obey a command you're not aware of. God does not move people to sin, He leaves them alone. Men act in accordance with God's will, they are not "obeying" when they sin. Men are following their own commands when they sin. That makes us accountable.
Choices always have parameters. Before salvation, those parameters are much narrower. After salvation, we are free and so our choice parameters broaden.
FK: "We follow our nature, unless it is changed by God."
And I thought you said we follow what God says we must do. Which is it, FK?
Both are true and consistent. We always follow our natures in accordance with God's plan. At salvation, our natures are changed. Where do you see a problem?
From what you are telling me sin is something that had to happen because God says so. If our rebellion and fall is the result of something God said must happen, knew it would happen, made sure it happens, then why is He 'offended?' I hope you realize you didn't answer my question.
God is offended, but He chose to "go through it" because He has greater good in mind. God chose to order the universe as He did, and that included sin in the world and His being offended at it. He could have ordered the universe differently, but He didn't.
(If you think this still doesn't answer your question, then just say so and I will try again. :)