The proclimation of a need to redo all Sacraments performed since 1969 is a proclimation of schism and heresy.
"The proclimation of a need to redo all Sacraments performed since 1969 is a proclimation of schism and heresy."
Actually.. I don't see where you could get that... if the new rites are questionable in validity... wouldn't it better safe than sorry?
Just because someone disagrees with sometihng from V2 doesn't make them a heretic, especially since V2 didn't change the essence of dogma, it change the way it was presented, along with several other things.
Now if I was to say "Jesus wasn't Divine, or Mary didn't stay a virgin her entire life, or Transubstantiation is a 'hocus-pocus' trick" -- that is heresy.
V2 started out harmless, and was turned into a hotbed of liberalism and modernism. It was only supposed to last 3 months, and the liberal cardinals/bishops took over...John XXIII knew that the toothpaste had been let out of the tube.