You should ensure that the items are correctly in the game. I haven't played WoW in months, but I remember Thottbot had quite a few fake user-entered items in their database. The stats don't look all that great, either.
In defense of WoW, however, I don't remember there being a deity you have to choose or a god that is worshipped in the game. They have a priest and a paladin class, but no mention of who they follow.
For the Horde!
They are in -- new patch. I had no issues with WoW until this. You can argue that there are other meanings for Trinity and/or Messiah -- but they're not common and not what most people think of when they see the items. I found it amusing that the first posts on the subject on thottbot were by posters trying to pre-emptively defend the names.
On the plus side, my wife will be happy that I'm no longer playing.