Bump for Michael Rose and for the faithful Catholic architecture department at Notre Dame.
This sounds like a trivial issue, but actually it will be an important test. Anyone who is thinking of supporting Ave Maria should pay attention to the outcome of this chapel controversy. If they back down, and scrap their plans, and respond to the wishes of their supporters, then there is a chance that something good could come out of this megalomaniac project in Florida. But if they bulldoze ahead with no concern for the objections of the faithful, then they will have made it clear that these "conservatives" like Fessio and Monaghan are essentially no better than the liberal bishops who have destroyed virtually every diocese.
=== But if they bulldoze ahead with no concern for the objections of the faithful, then they will have made it clear that
They lack sensibility where order, beauty and comfort are concerned. I can't imagine what the AC costs of a crystal palace in Florida would be.
I'm not sure I would go that far but, what must be known about Monaghan is his "my way or the highway" mentality. If Monaghan wants Frank Lloyd Wright it doesn't matter much what anyone else wants. I think the University will be solid and conservative but a lot depends on the influence Fr. Fessio has over Monaghan. Monaghan likes to be in charge, nothing wrong with that in business but when religion is involved unless those around him are very good and not dependant on his money, the look of this place will be less than what conservative Catholics had hoped for.
The architecture of the place isn't what interests me. I just want to know that if my kids go there, their faith won't be diluted or worse, ridiculed by the faculty. It sounds as though the Catholic Faith will be taught unapologetically, so that's all I need to know.
Monaghan is a Pelagian. He thinks he is going to save souls by spending money instead of by promoting holiness.
I vote for the design from Notre Dame.
I do believe the glass structure would be tough to air Condition and it might be hot as hell.
"essentially no better"
well, essentially in matters of faith, I think they would be better; but I agree that the "chapel" is impractical, etc. and they would have much more credibility to do it otherwise.
BTW, w.r.t. the Michael Rose bump: I encourage you to buy his books. He tells the truth, because he has the courage to speak out regardless of the fallout. He has a growing home-schooled family. BUY MORE BOOKS! ;)
If you have them, they make great gifts to people who may not be as well informed as you are . . .