Skip to comments.
Deutschland, Deutschland uber Poland
The Times of London ^
| May 8, 2003
| Roger Boyes
Posted on 05/07/2003 3:45:51 PM PDT by Piranha
May 08, 2003
Germany loath to let troops take Polish orders From Roger Boyes in Berlin
GERMANY has responded angrily to a proposal that its troops be deployed in northern Iraq under the command of Poland, one of the newest members of Nato. The United States recommended that Poland take over the military administration of northern Iraq, in charge of peacekeeping duties. The force under its command would number about 7,000, including contingents from Nato members such as Romania, Bulgaria and possibly Germany.
Peter Struck, the German Defence Minister, said he would look into the proposal, but was clearly opposed.
Poland, which contributed 200 men to coalition forces in Iraq, had promised 10,000 men for a peacekeeping force. This has shrunk to 1,500, with troops from other countries added. The US will be responsible for central Iraq and Britain for the south.
Neither Germany nor France had expected to take a leading military role in postwar Iraq, but the idea that Poland could take charge has stirred a hornets nest. President Kwasniewski of Poland will try to resolve the matter when he meets German and French leaders tomorrow, but there is no mistaking the dismay in old Europe as Poland flexes its muscles.
We would like to have German troops, Jerzy Szmajdzinski, the Polish Defence Minister, said after talks with Donald Rumsfeld, the US Defence Secretary. Im sure the United States would be interested in that.
The comment was intended to be practical rather than polemical. Poland recognises that it has no experience in leading a multinational force. But there is a Polish-German-Danish brigade based in Szczecin in northwest Poland that could be deployed in Iraq.
The German press has been particularly dismissive. Perhaps Gerhard Schröder, the Chancellor, should use the summit in Wroclaw to remind President Kwasniewski who exactly has been the strongest champion of Polish entry into the EU and Nato, Süddeutsche Zeitung sniffed.
The Poles have responded in kind. Germans and French, leave the Poles in peace! was the headline in Superexpress. We were right about the war, you do not have to teach us what to do in Iraq.
France and Germany do not find it easy to accept the Nato and EU newcomers as equals. This was clear when President Chirac chided Poland and other former members of the Soviet bloc for signing a letter of support for the US ahead of the Iraq war. They had lost, he said at the time, a good opportunity to stay silent.
The Germans also suspect that the US is again trying to drive a wedge between old and new Europe.
Poland has been taken aback by the Germans surly response. Where Germany sees conspiracy, Poland sees a chance to bring Germany back into the loop. Im afraid there is some misunderstanding, Wlodzimierz Cimoszewicz, the Foreign Minister, said. We would like as many European partners as possible.
Deep down most German politicians are unwilling to accept the concept; from the days of Bismarck until 1945, the Poles were seen as a subject people by Prussians and by Germans. The notion that a Polish captain would ever be allowed to give orders to a German soldier would take some getting used to.
TOPICS: Editorial; Extended News; Foreign Affairs; Free Republic; Front Page News; Germany; War on Terror
KEYWORDS: germany; iraq; nato; oldeurope; peacekeepers; poland; polanduberalles; postwariraq
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-79 next last
Some things never change. Imagine letting a group of Ubermenschen control the Aryan army!
1
posted on
05/07/2003 3:45:52 PM PDT
by
Piranha
To: Piranha
Yup. The Germans have always looked down on the Poles as a lesser race.
2
posted on
05/07/2003 3:47:42 PM PDT
by
goldstategop
( In Memory Of A Dearly Beloved Friend Who Lives On In My Heart Forever)
To: Piranha
It would be worth it top bring a platoon of germans just to see the film of them saluting the Polish general.
Serve them right. They have learned nothing apparently.
3
posted on
05/07/2003 3:49:03 PM PDT
by
dinok
To: Piranha
I've said it here several times to a mute response, we are going to have to protect Poland with force. Both from Germany and Russia. Niether country has learned they they are no better than anyone else. Their peacenicks are like ours they majically dissappear when they feel they are going to benefit from the death, torcher, and the subjegation of others.
4
posted on
05/07/2003 3:53:35 PM PDT
by
grapeape
(Hope is not a method. - Gen. Hugh Shelton)
To: Piranha
They had lost, he said at the time, a good opportunity to stay silent.
Does it get any worse than that?
Go Poland...
My father fought in North Africa with Polish troops, he said they were worth 5 Frenchmen and 4.5 Italians each.
5
posted on
05/07/2003 3:53:47 PM PDT
by
dinok
To: Piranha
Some things never change. Imagine letting a group of Ubermenschen control the Aryan army! I'm kind of hazy on the Third Reich lingo, but shouldn't that be Untermenschen
To: vbmoneyspender
You are correct.
Uber = above
Unter = below
7
posted on
05/07/2003 3:56:22 PM PDT
by
Poohbah
(Crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentations of their women!)
To: Piranha
...remind President Kwasniewski who exactly has been the strongest champion of Polish entry into the EU and Nato.Maybe the germans should be reminded that the US gave Poland the responsibility of Northern Iraq. That's the deal, take it or leave it.
"France and Germany do not find it easy to accept the Nato and EU newcomers as equals."
But they want to be equal to the US. I am getting dang close to giving up Bratwurst...
8
posted on
05/07/2003 3:59:19 PM PDT
by
rudypoot
To: grapeape
Nostradamus: Forces will come out of the east.
Ooowooowooowoooo.............................................
9
posted on
05/07/2003 4:01:39 PM PDT
by
ricpic
To: Piranha
Das typische Deutsche offensichtlich hat kein Selbstironiegefühl.
(Ich bin ein typische Deutsch-Texaner...)
10
posted on
05/07/2003 4:03:14 PM PDT
by
B-Chan
(Catholic. Monarchist. Texan. Any questions?)
To: Poohbah
You're right, I confused my ubers and my unters. I'm glad there are so many knowledgeable people on FreeRepublic. The free exchange of ideas in the marketplace comes through yet again.
11
posted on
05/07/2003 4:04:48 PM PDT
by
Piranha
To: rudypoot
don't worry about the bratwurst.
its probably made fresh and local to your town.
its the imported french wine or the german beer that would benefit the weasels.
12
posted on
05/07/2003 4:06:01 PM PDT
by
billl
To: Piranha
von der Maas bis an die Memel
von der Etsch bis an dem Belt
doesn't leave too much room for Poland...
To: billl
But if he insists on giving up bratwurst, kielbasa makes a fine replacement.
14
posted on
05/07/2003 4:07:00 PM PDT
by
Poohbah
(Crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentations of their women!)
To: Piranha
The axis of the unwilling, France, Germany and Russia, all three of them think they are going to be the boss.
It's going to be a hoot to watch.
15
posted on
05/07/2003 4:12:49 PM PDT
by
RJL
To: goldstategop
Just because you believe that weinerschnitzl is superior to kielbasa is no reason to go on a sniff. Come on boys, be nice.
16
posted on
05/07/2003 4:12:56 PM PDT
by
mc5cents
To: Piranha
This is entertainment.
17
posted on
05/07/2003 4:13:44 PM PDT
by
SoDak
To: Piranha
Time for the U.S. to revive the Warsaw Pact, and then join it. (Russia can take our place in NATO, and let them put up with the French.)
18
posted on
05/07/2003 4:14:19 PM PDT
by
Stultis
To: Stultis; hchutch
You should realize that forcing the Russians to put up with the French is only SLIGHTLY less of an "unfriendly act" than a full US strategic nuclear strike...
19
posted on
05/07/2003 4:16:20 PM PDT
by
Poohbah
(Crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and hear the lamentations of their women!)
To: Piranha
The Germans also suspect that the US is again trying to drive a wedge between old and new Europe. France's Chiraq already drove the wedge home, with his infamous comments against the new EU candidates.
The US doesn't have to do anything but be a friend to our new Eastern European allies.
20
posted on
05/07/2003 4:17:42 PM PDT
by
RJL
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-79 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson