[RightWingMama]

I love Brian.

[Redbob]

That's all you're going to post?
You're just going to tease us and quit?

Where's the beef? Did he make her cry?

[Illbay]

You beat me by one minute! I thought that the debate was fairly even, actually. Janeane was still WRONG, but she was a heck of a lot better in expressing her views than any other celeb that I've seen.

[The Right Stuff]

hahahahaha! "The U.N. is NOT irrelevant"...stamping feet in frustration!

[hellinahandcart]

Don't apologize. Some other clown just posted one sentence about it in Breaking News, and the one sentence didn't even describe what happened.

[conservativecorner]

It's about time somebody questioned these blowhards of the left!

[techcor]

BTTT.

[arkfreepdom]

Brian clearly won. Janeane was reduced to "Fox is a pub mouthpiece and what pseudo-intellectual periodicals do you read, Brian" crap.

[kcvl]

She was po'd. ROFLOL! She was about to cry. lol!

She said, "why don't you invite someone that you respect on here". DUH! That would mean they wouldn't invite her.

[Amanda King]

Brian Kilmeade was terrific!!! He totally controlled the questioning so that Garofolo couldn't weasel out of her answers. She was really rattled!

I emailed the show to voice my support for Brian. (friends@foxnews.com)

[alancarp]

On behalf of the anti-hollywood petition author (see tagline below), a hearty BTTT!

[cody32127]

It was great!! She said she gets all her info from her satilite dish, big deal I have one too. At one point She just stopped and rubbed her head like it was going to explode!!

[PokeyJoe]

Somebody stated on the other locked thread that Janeane Garofalo had more class.

I think Brian showed what it means to challenge the appeasement orthodoxy of Hollywood espoused by celebrities like Ms. Garofalo.

Ms. Garofalo tried to change facts to her side such as "Inspection can work" when, in fact, the only reason past inspections were successful was because of Iraqi defections. Inspections have never been successful where a country has not willingly disarmed.

I give KUDO's to Brian for having the cajones to challenge and not let her get away with perverting the truth. I'm also somewhat surprised that the the weather guy just sat there and offered Ms. Garofalo a cup of coffee.

I'm sure if the troops in Kuwait saw the exchange, they were root'n for Brian. I know that this old Marine was hoot'n and holler'n "rub it brian... go get her... yeah baby... take that you b*tch... bam ... "

I loved it. =)

[jigsaw]

Kilmeade is on Mike Gallagher radio show right now.

[CROSSHIGHWAYMAN]

These are the times that I wish I was a pundit on TV.

My reply to the naive Ms. Garafalo would be simple and to the point.

Would she trust her life to Saddam Hussein or George Bush?

And if we did nothing to protect ourselves proactively like the great stainmaker, would she trade places with one of the victims in the WTC on Sept 11th?

[way-right-of-center]

I never thought I would say this about another man. I love Brian Killmeade

THAT WAS GREAT!

[crz]

She was creamed by Brian. He kept firing her questions before she could go off on one of those typical socialist rants about this and that. She could not handle it and was looking this way and that way for an exit. Rolling of the eyes indicate arrogance and when he confronted her on her being a celeb, she lost it. Brian hit the nail on the head and she didnt like it. Typical of the socialists, they cant stand being confronted with facts nor can they answer questions straight up.

[RonF]

Yeah, I saw this. Just another "debate" that is really a shouting match where whoever behaves the most ill-mannered and yells loudest "wins", while the so-called "moderator" sits there and does nothing to ensure that the discussion stays on some kind of track and the two participants respond to each other instead of changing the subject each time they hear something they don't want to respond to. I give the kudos to Jeanne Garofalo not by force of argument, but purely on the basis that she's better mannered.

And the line about "Why should we listen to you, you're just a celebrity" - while I fully agree with the spirit of the statement, the reality is that it's a great way to change the focus from the substance of an argument to the person making it, thus neatly avoiding having to actually debate the issue. "Why do you think you're here?" - inviting someone to debate an issue, and then attacking the basis on which they were invited instead of discussing the issue that they were invited there to debate is also a great sidetrack to change the focus from the issue, and quite rude besides. If you don't want to feed the celebrity machine, then don't invite them.

[Republican Red]

I saw it and loved it. Kilmeade was great. I've seen Garafalo before and I would give her credit for appearing on Fox and not staying on more friendly territory except all she did was spew what magazines she reads. She puts on her glasses and pretends to be some intellectual who reads "The Economist" and to her that gives her credability.
Kilmeade challenged her and she failed.

[RLJVet]

She replied, what does what my profession is have to do with anything?

She sure did and, more importantly, She said "what the H-E-double toothpicks. . . She was rattled.

There seems to be no correct way to go at it with the charismatic, moderatlely informed gang without taking criticism for being too - whatever, so he got onto her level. It was ugly - and beautiful.