Replies

THIRD time asking Polycarp a simple question which he has thus far refused to answer:

Is it your assertion or belief, which you seem to indicate that it was, that the BROTHERS mentioned in Mark 6:3 are the SONS of ALPHAEUS?

That seems to be what you are saying. Do I have that correct? Campion is now on record saying that he believes James AND JOSES were the sons of ALPHAEUS.

What say you polycarp?

That seems to be what you are saying. Do I have that correct?

I have said nothing regarding this point. I simply ignored you.

What say you polycarp?

This thread is about the relative authenticity of the ossuary. Refute post 131. Thanks.

I will not answer any further theological questions on this thread from you. Don't bother asking, and don't bother trying to put words in my mouth.

Refute post 131.

THIRD time asking Polycarp a simple question which he has thus far refused to answer:

For the last week you have spent much time trumpeting this ossuary as authentic and as one that crushes that Catholic position on Mary.

Scriptural explanations of differing thoughts have taken up multiple threads, as a result of this ossuary.

I have posted a thread that refutes the authenticity of the ossuary.

You had your chance to crow.

Now refute posts 1, 5, 131, and 206...

AND STOP TRYING TO CHANGE THE SUBJECT!!!

yOU KNOW YOUR OSSUARY HAS BEEN DISPROVEN, SO YOU'RE SIMPLY TRYING TO CHANGE THE SUBJECT.

No more theological questions from you till you refute posts 1, 5, 131, and 206.

Stop trying to run away and trying to change the subject, Berned.

And simply assassinating the character of the author does NOT REFUTE his arguments in post 1, and neither have you addressed posts 5, 131, nor 206.