Posted on 07/26/2002 7:29:08 AM PDT by blam
Friday, 26 July, 2002, 13:08 GMT 14:08 UK
Astronomers see comet break-up
The fragments are strung out in space
By Dr David Whitehouse
BBC News Online science editor
Astronomers in the Czech Republic and Hawaii have seen Comet 57P/du Toit-Neujmin-Delporte splinter into at least 19 fragments. Initial observation from the 1.2-metre (3.9-foot) telescope at Mount Palomar in California, US, on 11 July appeared to show a companion to the comet.
Further work done the following day at the Klet Observatory in the Czech Republic then confirmed the comet had actually split apart.
Pictures taken from Mauna Kea in Hawaii with the University of Hawaii 2.2-metre (7.2-ft) telescope on the nights of 17 and 18 July revealed a host of tiny mini-comets strung out in a line trailing behind the parent body.
Thermal stress
The fragmentation of Comet 57P/du Toit-Neujmin-Delporte was probably triggered by thermal stresses within the nucleus due to it being warmed by sunlight.
Astronomers believe that as the comet neared the Sun, the heat from the star was sufficient to start evaporating the water-ice and other ices bound up in the rocky nucleus.
Linear's demise was caught by Hubble
Since the ice and rock are intimately mixed, the warming and evaporating ice produces great thermal and physical stresses on the body of the nucleus.
Under normal circumstances, only vapour and tiny dust grains fly off the surface of the nucleus, producing a long tail. Occasionally, however, the stress is great enough that entire chunks of the nucleus also break away.
It is not uncommon for one or two companions to be seen near a comet that has fragmented.
A similar situation was seen some years ago with observations of Comet Linear C/1999 S4 made by the Hubble Space Telescope. In that case, the fragments were short-lived, and fizzled out after only a few days.
Fragile object
The fragments from Comet 57P/du Toit-Neujmin-Delporte are trailing alongside and behind the comet over an apparent distance equivalent to the apparent size of the full Moon.
At the comet's distance this means that some of the fragments are about one million kilometres (620,000 miles) from the main nucleus.
Researchers believe that the fragments are large enough to be around for several weeks, allowing astronomers to watch how they evolve, which should give some insight into the make-up and fragility of the comet.
Detailed measurements reveal that some of the components are 250,000 times fainter than can be seen with the unaided eye and others some 10 million times fainter. This suggests that the fragments are a few hundred metres in size.
Comet 57P/du Toit-Neujmin-Delporte was discovered in 1941 by the three people for whom it is named. The 57P just means it is the 57th comet in the list of comets that have been seen on two of their passages around the Sun. (The first comet in this list, 1P, is the famous Comet Halley's.)
Shoemaker-Levy 9 broke up before it struck Jupiter
Let's think about this. Would cracks in the body of the comet cause it to break apart and string pieces along behind? For the coma, the tail, the particles are very tiny and solar wind can move them easily, but the bigger pieces that can be seen individually would not be so easily deflected.
Another thing is that the pieces stay in a cluster, a peloton, rather than being further moved from the cluster, unlike the tail that spreads out forever.
So what forces the chunks apart to begin with and then stops acting? It's the volatiles that are thoroughly mixed in with the body of the comet. A piece of ice down inside the body of the comet would remain frozen until the chunk it is attached to breaks free. Then the piece of ice begins to evaporate and the gas acts like an ordinary rocket exhaust slowly pushing the chunk away from the main body for a while until the ice is evaporated completely.
Differential thermal expansion causes cracks, but ice and other voilatiles provide the motor.
Yes, let's do.
I think it is the result of Comet-Global Warming and it must be stopped. Quick! Someone gather the experts to Kyoto again (and don't forget Algore) and see how this can be pinned on American expansionism and our obvious exploitation of natural cometary resources. America's industrial might must be crushed to save all of the other comets of the universe.
Now, what kind of resource taxation can the UN place on American Industry to stop this.
Works for me. However, wouldn't the fractured pieces continue to move away from the main body and themselves. Wouldn't gravity be to small to tug them back in?
Just a minute...I can make out...words...it says...Leave Europa Alone...
The forces that cause the initial separation would be fairly small so that relative velocities would also be small. Eventually the pieces would be distributed over a goodly part of the original orbit, but this would happen slowly. Right, mutual gravity would cease to be a factor fairly soon. We might be able to watch the cluster continue to spread out if the whole group stays within viewing range.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.