Posted on 05/31/2002 10:53:33 AM PDT by CedarDave
Friday, May 31, 2002
Johnson Frees Woman Abused by Jail Guards
Journal Staff Report
Gov. Gary Johnson took the rare step Thursday of commuting the six-year sentence of an inmate a woman sexually assaulted by Doña County jail guards while incarcerated for credit-card fraud.
Belinda Dillon was sentenced to more time than her assailants, a fact noted by the governor in announcing the commutation in a news release.
"Belinda Dillon is a victim of the drug war and this state's drug problems," Johnson said. "She received a harsh sentence for her nonviolent crimes while ... those who abused and mistreated her received collectively less time for their sexual offenses. It is morally and ethically appropriate to restore some semblance of justice to this situation by commuting her remaining sentence."
Dillon, 24, was convicted of stealing less than $1,000 from a family member, apparently due to her addiction to cocaine. The victim had asked that Dillon not be incarcerated, but a Doña Ana County judge sentenced her to six years.
Dillon had been released, but was sent to prison on a parole violation.
She has been serving her sentence in the state women's prison in Grants since 2001 and should be released today.
While she was an inmate at the Doña Ana County Detention Center in 1998, corrections officers sexually assaulted her over a two-month period while she was being kept in a medical observation cell out of sight of a hall video camera.
According to an investigative report by the Journal in 2001, she testified that the guards fondled her breasts and vagina through a food porthole in the cell door.
Of six law-enforcement officers implicated in the assault, three were convicted of criminal sexual penetration or attempted criminal sexual penetration, the Governor's Office said. Two officers received 18 months in prison, and another received a year in prison.
Dillon attempted suicide while in jail, writing the names of the officers in blood on the floor of the jail cell.
She later filed a civil lawsuit against the county, which has been settled, said Paul Kennedy, who with Mary Han represented Dillon on probation violations and in the federal lawsuit.
Copyright 2002 Albuquerque Journal
I was doing that very thing in Pheonix years ago. A mexican fellow received one year for shoplifting a ham. The next guy before the judge was white and received one year probation for driving over a mexican in a cross walk and killing him.
I remember being quite amazed at the time.
But the example you point out is simple bigotry.
What does this have to do with the article? Belinda Dillon doesn't sound like an Hispanic name.
Sentencing has a lot to do with how a particular judge feels at sentencing time.
I used to think of the court room as despensing justice . . . I now think of them despensing punishment by fiat.
This article is just another example of that.
She may have done those things voluntarily figuring she could turn it into a get out of jail free card.
I was wondering the same thing. Maybe they refused to feed her unless she did? Quite cruel.
Somehow I'm doubting that six different guards where all doing the same thing without her either coercing it or inviting it.
I think this woman may have just found a new scam to be used on the system and the Gov. fell right into it.
Blood in Cell IDs Assault Suspects
By Mike Gallagher
Journal Investigative Reporter
It doesn't make much difference whether the jail is new or old, the rape of inmates in county lockups is costing taxpayers.
And guards have done some of the raping. The Journal found more than two dozen rape cases in recent years that led to criminal charges filed against corrections officials.
The average settlement for female inmates sexually assaulted by corrections officers at the Bernalillo County Detention Center is more than $100,000. There have been more than half a dozen such cases in recent years.
Nobody knows how much Belinda Dillon's case is going to cost Doña Ana County.
The 23-year-old woman tried to commit suicide by slitting her wrists. She wrote the names of the officers she said assaulted her in blood on her jail cell floor.
Two officers have been convicted of molesting her. Charges against others are pending.
Dillon was arrested for credit-card fraud in May 1998 and was released in December.
Initially she was kept in E-pod, the women's unit. Then she was transferred to a medical observation cell that was not in the line of sight of a hall video camera.
She testified at the criminal trial of one officer that guards would talk to her over an intercom.
"Do you want to take off your clothes?" she said guards asked her. "Would you like to dance around?"
It was "the same thing they all said."
The officers continually talked to her over the intercom "asking me if I would let them both have intercourse with me at the same time. The conversation they went on about how they wanted to do me for quite some time."
She testified that one officer fondled her breasts and vagina by sticking his hand through the food port. She stood there while he did it.
"He had control of whether I slept, whether I ate," she told the jury. She said she was afraid of being raped and did what she was told.
Dillon's testimony is similar to that of the female inmates who filed lawsuits for being sexually assaulted in the San Juan County Jail.
Joe Romero, an attorney who represented most of the dozen inmates who filed claims, said all the women assaulted by guards felt they had no choice but to submit because of the total control the officers had.
"That's why it's a felony for a guard to have even consensual sex with an inmate," Romero said.
Dillon didn't report the food port incident, or others with different officers, at the time they occurred.
"I was afraid ... retaliation. Knowing I was going to be there for a long time, and that anything could happen between then and the time I was released from there."
When Dillon tried to commit suicide, she wrote the names of the officers in her blood on the cell floor. But first she wrote: "Who raped Belinda? Who did Belinda? Who didn't do Belinda?"
She testified that she then wrote, in blood, the names of every guard she had encounters with. The "note" went all the way to the cell door.
Dillon was found by corrections officers making a security check. She testified that one of the officers responding was one of her assailants, and that "terrified" her because he would see the bloody message.
"They put some butterfly tape over the cuts, and took my uniform, took the mattress out of the room and everything else that was in the room, toilet paper and everything, and threw me back in there the way it was with the blood writing on the floor," she said.
Later that day, she was asked to write a statement about what had happened to her. She did, listing the officers she said had sexually assaulted her over the past weeks.
She gave a 28-page diary to jail officials that recounted the assaults.
But none of that was forwarded to local law enforcement authorities not the diary, not the photographs of the bloody message and not Dillon's statement.
Dillon was released from jail and more than a year passed.
Another female inmate contacted the Sheriff's Department in 1999 with allegations that women inmates were being sexually assaulted.
The subsequent investigation led to Dillon and to the indictments of six corrections officers. Two have already been convicted.
Dillon's lawsuit is pending in federal court. * Sexual attacks in county jails, including some that involve guards, cost N.M. taxpayers
Copyright 2001 Albuquerque Journal
While I agree Miss Dillon might have deserved more time in prison, I don't think she deserved to be humiliated like this.
Her complaint was not forwarded to authorities as it should have been. It was ignored. That's illegal.
Yeah, that's the first thing I thought of, too.
This news article is so poorly written that it is difficult to follow, and tougher yet to find any reason to agree with this scumbag governor.
Dillon attempted suicide while in jail, writing the names of the officers in blood on the floor of the jail cell.
LOFL! Yeah. Okay. I believe this.
She later filed a civil lawsuit against the county, which has been settled....
Translation: She's a useless crack whore and a con-artist.
....said Paul Kennedy, who with Mary Han represented Dillon on probation violations and in the federal lawsuit.
So is the scumbag lawyer.
And notice the plural in "probation violations".
That's true, but it still doesn't mean she was telling the complete truth.
Dillon was released from jail and more than a year passed. Another female inmate contacted the Sheriff's Department in 1999 with allegations that women inmates were being sexually assaulted. The subsequent investigation led to Dillon and to the indictments of six corrections officers. Two have already been convicted.
We have been having quite a spate of bad Corrections Officers here on Long Island.
I don't always believe the authorities.
Another female inmate contacted the Sheriff's Department in 1999 with allegations that women inmates were being sexually assaulted. The subsequent investigation led to Dillon and to the indictments of six corrections officers. Two have already been convicted.
I would say that there was pretty strong evidence, which was "never forwarded to local law enforcement authorities", for this to have been instigated by investigation, and result in two (so far) subsequent convictions.
BTW, Lancey...I hope you get in a similar position some day...you might learn a little about compassion.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.