Posted on 03/30/2002 11:37:49 AM PST by a_Turk
And it kept being "a mistake" for five hours, and multiple waves of attack? Give me a ****ing break, man.
You accuse others of "ascribing to Jews every bad thing they can think of." I suggest that YOU will give Israel every conceivable break no matter WHAT they do. It is YOUR prejudice that is evident, not ours.
I am able to distinguish between JEWS--adherents of a particular religion--and ISRAEL, a secular state, a government like any other.
The attack on the Liberty wasn't made for religious purposes--"The Jews" were NOT out to get "American Christians" or whatever--but for POLITICAL purposes. The Israelis did not want the U.S. to know what they were up to--and some Israeli government officials may have even believed the U.S. was prepared to support Egypt.
So there is no reason to drag "anti-Semitism" (typically your only argument when you can't refute FACTS) into the debate.
As for the "investigations," they were bogus. LBJ--a man not known to be particularly worried about losing a few American lives for a political cause--decided that Israel would make a good hedge bet in the middle east against the growing Soviet influence among Arab states like Egypt and Syria, and so he went along with the charade.
The men who were there saw it quite differently, however.
I tried once more to involve you in a discussion, but your miond is closed like a door of an abandoned house.
I have said much more that issues relaetd to Jews and Israel. My main point was not related to Jews or Israel, but to the founding principles of this country.
You have not addressed it even with a word. I guess, this is waht your upbringing dictates: it's not the content of what is said, but the affiliations of the person who speaks.
Your position is at odds with the founding principles of this country, and you chose not deny that. That is a positive step.
As I said earlier, that was my last attempt, and I shall not write to you again. You will have to continue simmering in your narrowmindedness and hatred without me.
I do not find this to be funny at all, however.
Was it a massacre? yes. Was it pre-planned? no. That is exactly how I percieved this to be without being there myself.
Under some circumstances, the extreme elements in a movement or an army get out of countrol. The important part is how that movement or army act afterwards: are they appalled and try to punish the perpetrators, or they find excuses and cover it up. If the latter course is taken, then, unfotunately, the bad deed rubd off on the whole nation.
Perhaps, the army in this case could have done more to disassociate itself from the atrocity. Since it appears it had not done so, now the accusations level at it and the nation are numerous, not always fair, and quite possibly egagerated. But theirs was the initiative in the first place.
Maybe the same reason dead people, people not living there, or people in prison voted for Gore in Florida? 8)
Spar, BTW your stats are way off, the 28th suffered less than 2,000 KIA during the liberation of Srebrenica. ( less than 20% casulties) As most observers who have examined the operation have concluded, the RSA failed to annhilate the 28th BiH division.
Perhaps, the army in this case could have done more to disassociate itself from the atrocity. Since it appears it had not done so, now the accusations level at it and the nation are numerous, not always fair, and quite possibly egagerated. But theirs was the initiative in the first place.
Serbs have never been accredited with being a PR genius. However, what Spar posted regarding Karadzich screaming at General Mladich exposes some, only some of how even Mladich may have lost control of some of the White Eagles and his own troops to the shock and anger of the atrocities done by the BH Oric troops.
The outnumbered & thinly stretched RSA may have failed miserably in their attempt to annhilate the 28th. But one can safely doubt that the RSA failed as much as you suggest. The RSA may have been poorly deployed in the aftermath of the destruction of Nasir Oric's HQ, but they didn't 100% fail.
The UN forensic experts testified that they found at least 600 KIA of the 28th. It is unlikely that intercine fighting among the 28th killed more than that.
We have also had problems of our own. However, this last action seemed like an act of true stupidy, more in keeping with the traditions of America's beaurocracies than its military establishments. Recent episode of Elian Gonzales a perfect example.
The outnumbered & thinly stretched RSA may have failed miserably in their attempt to annhilate the 28th. But one can safely doubt that the RSA failed as much as you suggest. The RSA may have been poorly deployed in the aftermath of the destruction of Nasir Oric's HQ, but they didn't 100% fail. The OpOrder was not to annihilate the 28th, only to retake Srebrenica and render the unit ineffective/inoperable for a while. Mladic wanted to get the war done with before next winter, he did not want to keep fighting this war. He was getting tired of the civil war, so he ordered the "the militarized safe havens" to be demilitarized in accordance to UN Safe Haven order.
The UN forensic experts testified that they found at least 600 KIA of the 28th. It is unlikely that intercine fighting among the 28th killed more than that.true, it would be very difficult to differintiate between a "Muslim" AK round or a "Serb" AK round. You can only speculate and never know if you are correct upon those testimonies. Of course, we know the crediblity of the UN/NATO experts have been, with the 8,000- 6,000- 1000 bodies....
Yes, So-Smart, indeed election fraud would be the case if they have identified these very people on the list as those among the dead. But have they? Do you know - does anyone know?
Given that 3,010 is almost 40% of the total of "missing", and assuming they were all killed, then about every other or every third body found would in probability be identified as one of them. Yet I haven't heard that this is the case - of course access to comprehensive and specific data on the findings is seemingly unavailable to the public.
If they HAVEN'T identified and matched any of these men, and given that they are thousands bodies short in the claimed number of "missing and presumed dead" - 8,000, and given that the odds of not finding people who make up a substantial part of the total after hundreds have been identified would become infinitesimally small, odds are much greater that these people are alive (or were alive after 1995) and likely living in Bosnia or other countries at this point.
Apparently, euthanasia is illegal in Bosnia, and that is what the Dutch minister is bemoaning.
Would you be willing to play by the rules of war or would you use your strength to gain the advantage to win?
There were deaths, but not in the making of how the media and certain governments orchestraded the fight. There were three mass graves, one for civilians and the other two were of Serb and Muslim military deaths.
Where is the boot Tragically Single, or has he run already? Too bad he was not there during the 93-95 time frame, otherwise, he would have witnessed the truth.
No matter how well planned, Gen M. never suspected that a few companies of RSA infantry could have rendered a full entrenched division into a mob of fleeing fighters. Gen. M. only wished to demilitarize the zone by making it impossible for the execution squads of the 28th BiH to operate.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.