In this case, for the first time ever, it posted the full text of every brief filed in a case. Because of the fast schedule, only 14 attorneys managed to get briefs in. Only one of them -- mine -- urged the Court to "strike" the Florida Supreme Court decision and "do nothing else."
As it turned out, the Court neither affirmed nor reversed the Florida SC in round one. It "vacated" (struck) the decision and did nothing else. And the Court did that unanimously.
Anyone who is a glutton for punishment can put up a link and read all these briefs. In that case the ACLU was on the other side, supporting Gore. In this case the ACLU is on our side, opposing Shays-Meehan.
Billybob
Any way, the point is, this will not go away just because the Court strikes this down again. The Senate doesn't care what the Constitution says and some of them will bring it up again and again.
If Bush were to veto the bill and point to the court decisions that say this is unconstitutional, he also puts the scum on the defensive and lives up to his oath of office. By signing this bill, Bush loses the main reason many people voted for him. They thought he was honorable and could be trusted.
The political strategy the administration is following may be too slick by half. They stand to lose more than they gain.
A month or so ago, Rove was whining about the millions of Christians who stayed home in the 2000 election. If millions of conservatives stay home in 2002 because of this, we lose on two fronts.
No. 00-836, Bush v. Palm Beach County Canvassing Board et al?
Petitions, Oppositions, Replies, etc.
No. 00-949 (00-A504)
No. 00-942
Nos. 00-836 and 00-837
Disposition of Petitions
Briefs on the Merits
No. 00-949
Nos. 00-836 and 00-837
Joint Appendix
Briefs for Amici Curiae
No. 00-949
Nos. 00-836 and 00-837
Oral Arguments
No. 00-949
Nos. 00-836 and 00-837
Opinions