Posted on 10/11/2025 10:30:12 AM PDT by Decombobulator
Terrence McBride finds himself stuck.
He longs for his friends and family in Georgia and Texas, along with the job he was supposed to start at a golf course in Atlanta.
But the 63-year-old is recovering from a heart attack while living in a cramped rooming house in Saint John, N.B. — a city that’s unfamiliar. He says he feels emotionally and physically drained, just like his bank account.
His troubles began after he pulled up to the U.S. border in Calais, Maine on April 10. He told officials he’s an American citizen, but carries a Canadian passport.
“Here’s my name. Here’s everything,” he said, describing the interaction. “They look me up.”
McBride was born in Canada but adopted by American parents as a baby in the early ‘60s. Despite insisting he’s an American citizen, the adoption records and documents he showed at the border weren’t enough proof.
“I spent my whole life assuming I’m American,” he said. “A couple of times I’ve crossed the border and they’ve said, ‘Hey, just so you know, you might need some stuff the next time, but no big deal,” he said. “Suddenly, it’s a big deal.”
McBride said he was detained for about a day-and-a-half as officers questioned him and officers sorted through his files. He said he was treated well and released, but was told not to try to cross into the U.S. again until he secures either an American passport or citizenship number.
As McBride made calls to dig up the information needed while trying to hire a U.S. immigration lawyer, he had a heart attack. He eventually ended up in hospital in Saint John.
“I thought I was dying, I just thought it was stress. I laid there for two days on the bathroom floor,” he said.
‘I want to go home’
For nearly six months, McBride has lived in hotels, his pickup truck and now a rooming house he describes as squalor.
McBride, who loves dogs, had to give up his beagle because of his poor health. He says he’s desperate to return to his normal life.
“I want to go home,” he said, getting emotional. “They’re the people that make me feel valued enough, loved, appreciated and thought of. I want to go there, because I don’t have that. I don’t have that here.”
McBride tried to retain a lawyer in New York but didn’t have enough money to cover the cost. He’s started an online fundraising campaign to try to help his cause, but expects he’ll need thousands of dollars and so far has raised less than $400.
“What a great idea to offset the feeling of abandonment, loss, bewilderment of how alone I have felt through this whole experience,” he said.
Kelley Ortega, a U.S. immigration attorney at Jaime Barron in Washington State, said when McBride was adopted in the ‘60s, the process would’ve required his parents to make him a permanent resident — also known as a green card holder — then a separate process to request he become an American citizen.
“This information, even if it’s 60 years or so old, is contained within immigration files,” she said.
“One of the worst violations of immigration law, unfortunately, which is why I think it took the turn that it did, is falsely claiming U.S. citizenship,” she added. “So the minute that he probably said that I am an American or I am a U.S. citizen, but he’s holding a Canadian passport, the officers are starting to figure out if that there’s any truth to that.”
Ortega said it’s up to the traveller to prove they are who they say they are, even if they’re an American citizen. But he believes there may be ways for McBride to get the information he needs to get a U.S. passport, noting he was a military service member with the U.S. navy and they may have information on file.
She suggested filing a Freedom of Information Act Request with U.S. immigration, saying she’s had files come back as quickly as 30 days, or as long as several months, but highlighted timelines could be contingent on the current government shutdown.
The attorney said travellers should expect increased enforcement and stricter application of the rules under the Trump administration.
For McBride, digging up all the paperwork means a lot of time and money.
“It’s just chiseling away in my heart and my heart’s breaking,” he said.
In a statement sent Friday afternoon, Hilton Beckham, the assistant commissioner of Customs and Border Protection, said individuals who remain outside the United States for more than one year must obtain a valid SB-1 visa from their nearest U.S. embassy or possess a U.S. re-entry permit to seek re-entry.
“Mr. McBride was permitted, as a matter of discretion, to voluntarily withdraw his application for admission and return to Canada. There is no impediment preventing him from re-applying for admission to the United States in the future, provided he complies with all relevant laws and procedures,” said Beckham.
Beckham says it’s a “privilege” to enter the U.S. with a visa, not a right.
“Under U.S. immigration law, all individuals seeking entry are considered aliens and deemed inadmissible until they demonstrate to a Customs and Border Protection officer at a U.S. Port of Entry that they are either U.S. citizens or admissible under applicable laws.”
What a mess!
In my humble opinion, you are not an American citizen if you carry a different passport. Dual citizenship should not exist. Generation zero foreigners, even naturalized, should not be allowed to be elected to Congress.
Why does the guy have a Canadian passport?
He knew what he did when is applied for it.
What the hell is he doing with a CANADIAN passport since he claims to be a citizen of these UNTED STATES?
noting he was a military service member with the U.S. navy
WTF again? Didn't the NAVY want to sort out his actual citizenship?
I have the feeling we're not being told all relevant facts, here ...
McBride tried to retain a lawyer in New York but didn’t have enough money to cover the cost.
So at 63 yo he still had a Canadian passport? It never occurred to him to get that straight? Yeah.. right.
Agree; it's an abomination.
We can't control what other countries do ... eligibility for dual citizenship due to some other country's laws is beyond our control.
But we CAN treat acceptance of citizenship in another country as renunciation of US citizenship.
And the only solution is to open our borders to 100 million illegals.
That is the way it works.
When a bureaucrat tells you that you might want to get your stuff in order for "next time" please understand. You met one of the rare good ones and they are cutting you a lot of slack.
Go find out what is not right and get it fixed.
Or you are going to find yourself in hot water.
“they demonstrate to a Customs and Border Protection officer at a U.S. Port of Entry that they are either U.S. citizens or admissible under applicable laws.”
I like the government’s new attitude about immigration issues, “that’s a you problem.”
Good point. That should have been a wake up call to him to get things straightened out, and to get his American passport.
A sad story in some ways, but in telling the details, he had warning that he was in trouble by not having an American passport.
Should have gone in all the way a long time ago.
“I spent my whole life assuming I’m American,”
Obviously not true given he carries a Canadian passport.
I’ve always been told Canadia’s socialized medicine was awesome. Sounds like he lucked up.
“McBride was born in Canada but adopted by American parents as a baby in the early ‘60s. Despite insisting he’s an American citizen, the adoption records and documents he showed at the border weren’t enough proof.”
Then he is a U.S. citizen. This should be cleared up pronto!
"Doc, I tripped and I might've broken my wrist."
"Have you considered medically-assisted suicide?"
““I spent my whole life assuming I’m American,” “
Is that why you carry a Canadian passport and claim to be a Canadian citizen?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.