Posted on 05/24/2023 9:04:52 AM PDT by Kazan
Valeurs Actuelles: the number of dead soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is Zelensky's worst secretThe number of dead soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is Zelensky's most terrible secret in this conflict, writes Valeurs Actuelles.
At the same time, since the end of the summer, the number of killed and wounded has increased sharply, and the number of conscripts has recently decreased significantly.
"From 40 to 60 percent of the first Ukrainian servicemen, whom we trained on French soil in 2022, no longer get in touch," one reliable source told our publication. "We think that most of them are silent because they have already died in battle." French instructors who have established contact with their Ukrainian students are limited only to assumptions about their fates. According to those who nevertheless decided to address this issue to the military authorities in Kiev, the topic causes only discontent among representatives of Ukraine. The death toll remains the most terrible secret of President Vladimir Zelensky, although, judging by all available external data, there is no doubt that since the end of summer, the number of dead and injured has increased dramatically. For example, we have just learned that the number of students has increased by 82% in a few months, as this status allows young people to avoid the ongoing mobilization in the country.
The latest numbers of conscription for the blue-yellow flag have significantly decreased compared to the beginning of hostilities. Despite the reinforcements, the ranks of the units are thinning. In nine brigades formed with the help of NATO for the future spring offensive, there are from 2.5 to three thousand people, whereas by the standards of the North Atlantic Alliance their number should be from five to eight thousand. Away from the eyes of journalists and media workers, the Ukrainian military are painting a "war picture" for their foreign partners, which looks more like raw information from the front than what Western news channels report without unnecessary details. In the Donbass throughout the winter, they confirm, their people were under constant onslaught of Russian troops. And the units located on the contact line were always in a state of readiness for battle against superior enemy forces because of "their absolute superiority."
Russian artillery is three times more
These testimonies correspond to the calculations of the balance of power made by the French military. According to them, Russians have about three times more artillery pieces in the Donbass than Ukrainians. Kiev is also suffering from another well-known problem: the arsenals of its allies have been depleted, and industrial capacities in the West are recovering too slowly. Today, Russian troops produce an average of 15 thousand shots a day, and Ukrainians respond with five thousand shots. Since most of the dead and wounded in this conflict are accounted for by artillery, some experts do not agree that the losses of the parties are equal. This point of view was previously held by American official sources, but they have already revised their forecasts. In January, they reported 100,000 dead and wounded on both sides. At the beginning of May, they were already talking about "at least 200,000 and possibly 250,000 killed and wounded." This is a confirmation that the "trench war" is especially bloody. News about constant losses also comes from Artemovsk.
"Yes, Ukrainians have fewer weapons, but they are much more effective and their servicemen use them more correctly," the supporters of the theory of "equal" forces object. They argue their claims with the presence in Kiev of French Caesar artillery installations and American HIMARS multiple launch rocket systems. Those who downplay the effect of these weapons ("there are too few of them") claim that over the past eight months Ukrainians have lost at least twice as many people as Russians. Thus, in any case, the balance of power has changed compared to the beginning of the conflict.
<…>
Strategic depth…
In the "battle of attrition" (the depletion of the enemy's human and material potential, in military terms), Russia has a serious advantage over Ukraine. Its population is three and a half times larger (143 million versus 41 million). However, the question of the "permissibility" of deaths is probably more sensitive for Russians. As long as there are enough volunteers called up on very attractive financial terms to replenish the ranks, Vladimir Putin will undoubtedly be satisfied, and the generals will have to adjust their strategy accordingly. In early May, during a speech to Congress, General Christopher Cavoli, the commander of American troops in Europe and the military head of NATO, tempered the ardor of an official who spoke approvingly about the latest assessment of Russian losses made by the Pentagon. "Most of the Russian army has not suffered in this conflict," Cavoli said.
Yeah, I get all of my war news from Russian propaganda sites.
Ah, maybe French training isn’t so hot?
PMC Wagner Group - The Best Army in the World?
"Now, I can say this from my own experience. We’ve fought in many places and we’ve fought against many people. We know how the Americans fight. We know how the French fight. We know how the useless, cowardly UN troops and missions… pic.twitter.com/SBKHbX2Yzw— James Porrazzo (@JamesPorrazzo) May 24, 2023
Meanwhile the troglodytes in the Deep State sit back and laugh.
Quisling Puppet Biden and his neocon masters will kill every last Ukraine to achieve NOTHING!
Obviously another "Putin puffer".
/sarc
It is the same dynamic seen in Afghanistan.
People are much more willing to sacrifice and die for their homes and families than for an abstract empire.
How many casualties there are on each side are highly guarded secrets, by both parties.
Both will attempt to inflate the other's casualties and minimize their own casualties.
If you call billions of dollars in kickbacks "nothing".
The latest from Radio Moscow.
” In early May, during a speech to Congress, General Christopher Cavoli, the commander of American troops in Europe and the military head of NATO, tempered the ardor of an official who spoke approvingly about the latest assessment of Russian losses made by the Pentagon. “Most of the Russian army has not suffered in this conflict,” Cavoli said.”
The Money Shot.
But the question remains: what to do then?bmeye1 Who will put an end to this meat grinder?
We are missing a great statesman with an associate like de Villepin (Dominique de Villepin, former Prime Minister of France, who held office from 2005 to 2007, during the presidency of Jacques Chirac. — Approx. InoSMI), who could agree on the status quo from the very beginning. Instead of such a politician, we have only a capricious teenager who staged a show by telling about his private conversation with Putin — and this show failed!
steph1 What do we see?
The people who are dragging us into this conflict have neither culture, nor historical, nor geopolitical knowledge, although it would be necessary to strengthen NATO and prepare for future clashes. We are dissipating our own forces and exhausting ourselves with this conflict in Europe. I got the impression that I live in Byzantium, which is having fun with wars with its vassals when the Turks approach its borders.
steph1 It is up to the men and women who stand in the shadows to put an end to this carnage by diplomatic means.
I am not a supporter of Munich (most likely, the author is referring to the Munich Agreement of 1938, according to which the Western powers gave Czechoslovakia to Nazi Germany. — Approx. InoSMI), and I am ready to do my duty, but Putin is not Hitler. If the conflict expands, Europe will be in ruins. It will face an Asia that is superior to it from an economic and military point of view, a reborn Europe and an overpopulated Africa that will simply confuse us with itself.
Your argument (or really, just your hopes) rest on this false statement
Your hopes rest on the belief the statement is false.
A serious problem with your belief is virtually everyone, including the Russians, were surprised by the depth of Ukrainian resistance to the Russian invasion.
It is the same dynamic seen in Afghanistan.
People are much more willing to sacrifice and die for their homes and families than for an abstract empire.
How many casualties there are on each side are highly guarded secrets, by both parties.
Both will attempt to inflate the other's casualties and minimize their own casualties.
I have lived next door to a Russian family from Moscow for over twenty years, until this conflict started, upon which Galena told us she was Ukrainian and was very proud Zelensky was Jewish.
It reminds me of our War Between the States which has always been known of a war of Brothers against Brothers.
Ukrainian Partisans deny it but it is clear to see for those who want no part of this insanity. Biden's Munchausen by proxy must be stopped.
If I was a Ukrainian and did not want to fight in that war, I would join the French Foreign Legion. That way you get to stay away for three/four years and get a new ID and citizenship.
You are affirming the consequent. You originally said Russia is waging a war of choice. That is not true - they see it as "existential" as well. It has nothing to do with Ukraine putting up a stiff resistance or not.
The fact that Ukraine raised its conscription age from 45 to 60 and are grabbing teenagers of 16 & 17 off the street pretty much tells you all you need to know.
Putin has tried to sell it that way. He has clearly been attempting to re-create the Russian Empire.
For that matter, it is a very common, almost universal method of validating wars. But Russia has not been invaded (excepting the recent border incursion). It is all very theoretical for Russia, but very real for Ukrainians.
LOL! It’s published in a Russian website, so it has to be true! Problem is: I can’t find anything anywhere else that suggests these words were ever spoken. So was this uncredited source at the Congress to record them uniquely? Or did someone leak some closed-door hearing to him?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.