Posted on 05/16/2022 9:39:19 AM PDT by billorites
Who should run New York’s legal marijuana shops? Former pushers, according to Governor Kathy Hochul, who announced Thursday that those with a marijuana arrest record will be first in line for retail licenses.
Supporters of the plan frame it as both fair and good business sense. Those individuals most affected by the “war on drugs,” they argue, should get first shot at profiting from legal marijuana. And those with prior experience selling pot would just be transplanting their skills to a now-legal market. In reality, the proposal is yet another misstep in New York’s march to legalization. Running a reasonable legal regime means keeping the previous black market as far away as possible, not welcoming its participants in with open arms.
That’s clearly what New York’s leaders would like to do. The New York Times reports on Baron Fajardo, “a Harlem resident who plans to apply for a retail license. He was 16 when the police found him smoking marijuana in his hallway and arrested him. A half dozen other pot arrests followed as he moved from smoker to dealer.” The administration, the Times reports, wants to use preferential treatment to attract “legacy” candidates like Fajardo into the licit market.
In effect, that means handing control of the state’s nascent industry to individuals who didn’t comply with the law when selling marijuana was illegal. That will happen at the expense of other “equity” applicants—minority groups favored with half of legal pot licenses under New York’s law—who don’t share that history of lawbreaking.
Why would the skills involved in selling drugs illegally apply to the legal market? The latter entails tax compliance, legal administration, and otherwise navigating a highly regulated and scrutinized industry. The former, by contrast, selects for individuals skilled at dodging the law and extracting profits through coercion, not through commercial exchange.
To the extent they have justified it at all, marijuana-legalization advocates across the country have insisted that a legal market will suppress the illegal one, with its violence and gangs, much better than criminalization did. But from California to Colorado, outside-the-law markets have persisted in marijuana-legalizing states. Putting those who ran the old market in charge of the new one is a sure way to replicate the problem in New York.
If lawmakers want to redress the harms of drug arrests, meantime, handing out licenses is an inefficient way to do it. As several RAND Corporation scholars argue in a recent paper, the benefits to the handful who receive “equity” licenses are far smaller than the benefits from encouraging employment—a step that, in turn, runs a “distant second” to the benefits of simple expungement of those individual marijuana-related criminal records. After Virginia’s legalization, for example, the RAND scholars estimate that expungement would benefit 200,000 people, while the industry would employ about 10,000 and create at most a few hundred local entrepreneurs.
This is not to say that a marijuana license would not benefit some recipients. New York has promised $200 million to fund “social equity cannabis businesses”—inexplicably spending down two years of revenue from the industry—so success through sheer taxpayer largesse is certain, at least for now. But this relatively small aggregate benefit does not justify introducing those with black-market connections into the legal marketplace.
seems to me, gov wants the gig for themselves.
Wait. This isn’t the Bee?
“...That will happen at the expense of other “equity” applicants—minority groups favored with half of legal pot licenses under New York’s law...”
Gov is our pusher, our bartender the big pimp. The hand is always out, nothing is done without raining shekels upon the king.
I hear legalized marijuana in Colorado has turned out to be a big flop.......so what’s that definition of insanity again?
Reparations by any other name
Why not give the licenses to street hookers? They are already used to paying someone else 90% off the top. Instead of paying a pimp, they will pay the state and city governments.
I’ve been growing pot hydroponically for 30 years. The growing systems, seed stock, lighting, and nutrients are now A-1. For what a couple grams cost at a pot shop anyone can grow several ounces.
Next she will n9minate bank robbers to become bank presidents.
Growing dope is easier and cheaper than brewing beer.
But Big brother wants his cut!!!
Oregon, ie Portland, is a mess because of the legalization of drugs...
Nevertheless, I'm not sure society is well served by legalizing another intoxicant.
Everything was legal before the so-called "progressive" era. And we had a much better society then.
Better idea: legalize everything and outlaw leftists, commies and so-called "progressives"!
“Then there are the now known health benefits to cancer patients and folks with seizure disorders.
It can be ingested as an edible, or used as a low temp vape which takes away the tars that plagued it in the past.
It’s time has come.”
Pedophiles are always arrested while carrying an ample supply.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.